I’m back, and luckily nothing at all happened while I was away (okay everything happened while I was away). Lots and lots of links this week! Let’s get to it.
2026 We Need Diverse Books Mentorship Program Application – Applications are now open for We Need Diverse Books’ terrific mentorship program for creatives in four categories: Picture Books (text), Illustration, Middle Grade, and Young Adult! Winners will receive a year-long mentorship with an experienced children’s book author or illustrator.
Trump Sues Penguin Random House, ‘New York Times’ for $15 Billion – Ed Nawotka, Publishers Weekly – Jimmy Kimmel’s suspension after FCC pressure has dominated the headlines (and rightfully so), but it was not the only affront to free speech in the past few weeks. Donald Trump also sued Penguin Random House and the New York Times for $15 billion over Russ Buettner’s and Susanne Craig’s reporting and book Lucky Loser. This morning a judge threw out the case because a “complaint is not a public forum for vituperation and invective,” but gave his lawyers 28 days to file an amended complaint.
Texas A&M President to Step Down After Controversy Over ‘Gender Ideology’ – Pooja Salhotra, New York Times – In a less-noticed but very troubling development for the children’s book world, Texas A&M’s president, head of a public university it should be emphasized, resigned over a blowup over a children’s literature course that “recognized more than two genders” after a student filmed themselves arguing with the professor, who has already been fired.
Sally Rooney unable to collect award over Palestine Action arrest threat – Ella Creamer, The Guardian – And across the Atlantic, Irish author Sally Rooney has canceled all appearances in the U.K. because of the possibility of arrest due to her support for Palestine Action, which the U.K. labeled a terrorist group after they spray-painted some RDF planes (seriously).
The Worst Part of Tiny Bookshop Is Also the Most Accurate – Fran Hoepfner, Vulture – Gamers are complaining about virtual customers rejecting good book recommendations in the game Tiny Bookshop. Actual booksellers say it’s probably its most accurate feature.
Middle Grade Is Down but Never Out – Shannon Maughan, Publishers Weekly – It’s tough sledding these days for middle grade authors (fun times for me personally), but various industry figures are hoping to revitalize the category.
They Call us NPCs, Because That’s What they Want us To Be – Charlie Jane Anders, Happy Dancing – Why do right-leaning tech bros love calling marginalized groups NPCs (non-player characters)? Because that’s what they want them to be.
The Power of Developmental Editing – Elaine R. Frieman, Inside an Editor’s Brain – Editor Kristen Weber has a cool post from author Elaine R. Frieman about what it’s like to work with a developmental editor.
Curtis Brown Changes Hands – Sophia Stewart, Publishers Weekly – Congrats to my former colleague Elizabeth Harding, who is taking the reins at Curtis Brown Ltd. after many years being stewarded by the Knowlton family. Current CEO Tim Knowlton will assume an emeritus role, and Ginger Knowlton will remain at Curtis Brown as VP and an agent.
Let’s talk about ‘political violence’ – Taylor Lorenz, User Mag – In the wake of Charlie Kirk’s disturbing assassination and amid a devastating ongoing U.S.-backed genocide, it’s worth taking a step back and considering what is–and isn’t–considered “political violence” by elites and which deaths are recognized.
[Error: Irreparable invalid markup ('<a [...] h-[15px]">') in entry. Owner must fix manually. Raw contents below.]
<p class="syndicationauthor">Posted by Emmet Asher-Perrin</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/">https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824579">https://reactormag.com/?p=824579</a></p><post-hero class="wp-block-post-hero js-post-hero post-hero post-hero-horizontal">
<div class="container container-desktop">
<div class="flex flex-col mx-auto post-hero-container">
<div class="post-hero-content">
<div class="post-hero-tags font-aktiv text-xs tracking-[0.5px] font-medium uppercase">
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/articles/movies-tv/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Movies & TV 0">
Movies & TV
</a>
</span>
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/tag/peacemaker/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Peacemaker 1">
Peacemaker
</a>
</span>
</div>
<h2 class="post-hero-title text-h1"><i>Peacemaker</i> Makes a Lot of Bad Decisions in “Back to the Suture”</h2>
<div class="prose post-hero-description prose--post-hero">They made Adrian cry; it’s time to get mad.</div>
<div class="post-hero-wrapper">
<div class="post-hero-inner">
<p class="post-hero-author text-xs font-aktiv uppercase font-medium [&_a]:link-hover">By <a href="https://reactormag.com/author/emmet-asher-perrin/" title="Posts by Emmet Asher-Perrin" class="author url fn" rel="author">Emmet Asher-Perrin</a></p>
<span class="post-hero-symbol relative top-[-2px] hidden tablet:block">|</span>
<p class="text-xs uppercase post-hero-publish font-aktiv">
Published on September 19, 2025
</p>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-caption post-hero-caption-vertical [&_a]:link"><p>Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max</p>
</div>
<div class="quick-access post-hero-quick-access mt-[17px] tablet:hidden">
<div class="flex gap-[30px] tablet:gap-6">
<a href="https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/#comments" class="flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase translate-x-[1px] translate-y-[1px]">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 18 18" aria-label="comment" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-comment-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-comment-quick-access-">Comment</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<path fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" d="M6.3 18a.9.9 0 0 1-.9-.9v-2.7H1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 0 12.6V1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 1.8 0h14.4A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 18 1.8v10.8a1.8 1.8 0 0 1-1.8 1.8h-5.49l-3.33 3.339a.917.917 0 0 1-.63.261H6.3Z" />
<path stroke="#000" d="M5.9 14.4v-.5H1.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3-1.3V1.8A1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.8.5h14.4a1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.3 1.3v10.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3 1.3h-5.698l-.146.147-3.324 3.333a.417.417 0 0 1-.282.12H6.3a.4.4 0 0 1-.4-.4v-2.7Z" />
</g>
</svg>
0
</a>
<details class="relative quick-access-details">
<summary class="quick-access-share flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 22 22" aria-label="share" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-share-new-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-share-new-quick-access-">Share New</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="11" fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" />
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="10.5" stroke="#000" />
<path fill="#FFF" d="M5.993 13.464c.675 0 1.323-.266 1.806-.743l4.11 2.396a2.639 2.639 0 0 0 .368 2.451 2.583 2.583 0 0 0 2.227 1.043 2.59 2.59 0 0 0 2.09-1.3 2.64 2.64 0 0 0 .08-2.477 2.58 2.58 0 0 0-4.292-.54L8.344 11.94c.28-.616.31-1.319.086-1.958l3.952-2.303a2.564 2.564 0 0 0 4.263-.537 2.623 2.623 0 0 0-.078-2.46 2.573 2.573 0 0 0-2.075-1.293 2.566 2.566 0 0 0-2.213 1.033 2.622 2.622 0 0 0-.37 2.433L7.96 9.158a2.573 2.573 0 0 0-4.316.603 2.632 2.632 0 0 0 .172 2.501 2.58 2.58 0 0 0 2.178 1.202Z" />
<path fill="#000" d="M6.936 9.577c.322 0 .631.137.859.383.228.245.355.577.355.924 0 .347-.127.68-.355.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.859.383c-.322 0-.63-.138-.858-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.356-.925c0-.347.129-.679.356-.924.228-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm6.17-3.837c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.924 0 .347-.128.68-.356.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.924.227-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm0 7.883c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.925 0 .346-.128.679-.356.924a1.171 1.171 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.923.227-.245.536-.383.858-.384Zm-6.17-.681c.499 0 .978-.21 1.334-.586l3.036 1.888a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .272 1.93c.385.555 1.003.863 1.645.822.641-.04 1.221-.425 1.544-1.024a2.203 2.203 0 0 0 .059-1.952c-.286-.62-.841-1.044-1.48-1.13-.637-.085-1.272.18-1.69.705l-2.984-1.854c.207-.486.23-1.04.064-1.543l2.92-1.815c.415.522 1.046.784 1.68.7.633-.086 1.184-.507 1.468-1.123a2.188 2.188 0 0 0-.058-1.938c-.32-.595-.895-.977-1.532-1.018-.638-.041-1.251.264-1.635.813a2.179 2.179 0 0 0-.273 1.917L8.389 9.55c-.423-.534-1.07-.798-1.715-.702-.645.096-1.2.54-1.472 1.177a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .126 1.97c.352.59.958.948 1.61.947Z" />
</g>
</svg>
Share
</summary>
<div class="quick-access-bubble">
<ul class="flex gap-6 text-black list-none">
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=<i>Peacemaker</i> Makes a Lot of Bad Decisions in âBack to the Sutureâ&url=https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/” target=”_blank” title=”Twitter”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[15px]"="h-[15px]"" width="18" height="15" viewbox="0 0 18 15" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="twitter" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/" target="_blank" title="Facebook">
<svg class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" fill="currentColor" viewbox="0 0 12 22" width="100%" height="100%" display="block" transitionduration="normal" transitionproperty="none" transitiontimingfunction="ease-out" class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" aria-label="facebook" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M11.558.004L8.677 0C5.44 0 3.349 2.125 3.349 5.416v2.496H.452A.45.45 0 000 8.36v3.618a.45.45 0 00.452.447h2.897v9.127A.45.45 0 003.8 22h3.778c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.448v-9.127h3.387c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.447l.003-3.618a.452.452 0 00-.456-.448h-3.39V5.795c0-1.017.245-1.534 1.582-1.534h1.941c.25 0 .452-.2.452-.447V.457a.45.45 0 00-.452-.448l.01-.005z" fill-rule="nonzero">
</path>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/&media=&description=<i>Peacemaker</i> Makes a Lot of Bad Decisions in âBack to the Sutureâ” target=”_blank” title=”Pinterest”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[18px]"="h-[18px]"" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="pinterest" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://reactormag.com/feed/" target="_blank" title="RSS Feed">
<svg class="w-[17px] h-[17px]" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="rss feed" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<g clip-path="url(#clip0_1051_121783)">
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</g>
<defs>
<clippath id="clip0_1051_121783">
<rect width="17" height="17" fill="white" transform="translate(0.678711 0.414307)" />
</clippath>
</defs>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
</ul>
</div>
</details>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-media ">
<figure class="w-full h-auto post-hero-image">
<img fetchpriority="high" decoding="async" width="740" height="493" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-1-740x493.jpeg" class="w-full object-cover" alt="Rick Flag Sr. choking Chris Smith on the floor in Peacemaker's "Back to the Suture"" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-1-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-1-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-1-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-1-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-1.jpeg 1920w" sizes="(max-width: 740px) 100vw, 740px" /> </figure>
<div class="post-hero-caption post-hero-caption-horizontal [&_a]:link"><p>Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</post-hero>
<div class="wp-block-more-from-category">
<div>
</div>
</div>
<p>Sometimes the best jokes are seeing someone’s full name spelled out at a funeral.</p>
<div style="height:10px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Recap</h3>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-3-1100x733.jpeg" alt="Bordeaux and Harcourt face off in Peacemaker's "Back to the Suture"" class="wp-image-824582" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-3-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-3-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-3-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-3-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-3.jpeg 1920w" sizes="(max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max</figcaption></figure>
<p>Three years ago, we see Harcourt and Economos at Rick Flag Jr.’s funeral. Flag Sr. talks to Harcourt about wanting vengeance for his son’s death, and how he knew they were close. He wants Harcourt to give him the name of his son’s killer, but she can’t do that. She promises that the person who killed Rick Jr. will pay.</p>
<p>At the park, Chris arrives with A.R.G.U.S. everywhere, but he’s doing a great job staying hidden behind various civilians. It turns out that when Harcourt texted back “copacetic” at his request to meet, that was a warning word to keep him away. He tells her that he knew, but needed to ask her a question: whether them sleeping together meant anything. She tells him no and that he’s an idiot because now he’s surrounded with no hope of escape. Chris nabs one of the A.R.G.U.S. team as a body shield, but Sasha Bordeaux has a shot she can take that would kill him. Before she can make it, Harcourt charges in and knocks Chris unconscious.</p>
<p>Back at the cabin, someone calls to answer Adebayo’s ad, though they clearly think it’s for sex work (which Adrian eventually informs her of, along with the fact that he doesn’t kill sex workers, regardless of his vigilante code to kill people who break the law). Chris is brought back to HQ, where Flag demands that they turn off the security cameras in the interrogation room. He proceeds to brutally beat Chris while the man tries to apologize for killing his son. Outside, Harcourt gets Economos alone and demands that he book Chris’ arrest to save his life. Economos caves, and once it pops up in the system, Bordeaux goes and tells Flag. They release Chris to Adebayo and Adrian, not knowing that Rip Jagger is tailing them.</p>
<p>Flag explains to Bordeaux that he wanted Chris to think this was all about revenge to get his guard down. Bordeaux claims she’s impressed, and they wait to find out what Jagger learns. At cabin, Red St. Wild tries to poison Eagly, accidentally killing a fox instead, then shoots the wrong eagle. He finds himself surrounded by eagles, and the prime eagle symbol appears over Eagly. Red tries to apologize for attempting to kill the prime eagle, but the birds descend and begin pecking him to death. Chris tells Adebayo that Harcourt turned him over to A.R.G.U.S. for her job, and that he’s done with all of this. He asks to be left alone, and whistles for Eagly as Adebayo and Adrian drive off.</p>
<p>Chris leaves a note to his friends as Rip Jagger calls Fluery to let the team know they should head over. Then Chris opens the quantum door, but programs the device to close soon after he enters. He and Eagly walk through together, and Jagger follows, leaving a note telling A.R.G.U.S. where he’s gone. Adebayo gets one last text from Chris and u-turns right back to the cabin. They find the quantum door missing, along with Rip and Chris’ notes. Adebayo takes the door device, and she and Adrian leave as A.R.G.U.S. rushes to the scene.</p>
<p>The 11th Street Kids all get together back at Harcourt’s apartment, and Adebayo reads Chris’ goodbye note and explains what he did. She asks Harcourt if she really turned Chris over, and she explains that Bordeaux would have murdered him if she hadn’t knocked him out. Adebayo heads into the other room and finds Adrian crying, and holds him while she cries too. Harcourt tells the group that they need to take the door device somewhere more robust to use it so they can find Chris. In the alt-dimension, Keith tells Chris they’ve got a kaiju to fight, and he suits up with his family. After the battle, Chris heads to see Emilia and the two rush to embrace.</p>
<div style="height:10px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Commentary</h3>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-2-1100x733.jpeg" alt="Adebayo and Adrian on the steps of the cabin while Ads is on the phone in Peacemaker's "Back to the Suture"" class="wp-image-824583" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-2-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-2-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-2-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-2-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-2.jpeg 1920w" sizes="(max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max</figcaption></figure>
<p>You’d assume that our kick-the-dog moment of this episode was intended to be the (multiple!) animal deaths—when it’s really making Adrian cry.</p>
<p>This episode is a mess cohesively, mostly due to the fact that we’re still stuck in the midway storytelling points, but also due to the Eagly side plot being… awful? I can’t think of any better descriptors, it’s just bad, back to front, and reads like it was shoved into the scripts just to give Michael Rooker something to do. James Gunn claimed, as I mentioned in a previous recap, that he wanted to give Eagly his own nemesis, and while I’m not sure if the guy is fully vanquished yet, the question remains: <em>Why?</em> Why does Eagly need his own antagonist, and more importantly, why does it have to be a human one?</p>
<p>I would’ve happily watched an entire side plot where Eagly had a grudge match with a puma or a bear, or something. Whatever is going on here with this faux vision-questing eagle spirit Hitchcockian-attack nonsense needed absolutely no time in this episode. It’s distracting, confusing, and offers nothing to the story whatsoever. Is it mired in racial insensitivity toward Indigenous Peoples, too? Maybe! I’d have to understand what was going on here to be sure, though—which only makes the sloppiness read as intentional.</p>
<p>It’s unfortunate because without these weird glaring misfires, the core of the second story’s season is so clear. We’ve got a story about Chris Smith, who is trying to handle the death of his father by controlling the rest of his relationships. But you <em>can’t</em>. You can’t control other people and make them fit your personal patterns, no matter how misunderstood you’ve been in your life. Adebayo finding Adrian crying brings that message home without a word: Chris wants Keith back in his life, so he abandoned the brother he <em>has</em>. </p>
<p>And of course he doesn’t really get that—Chris was a little brother. In his mind, he can’t be Adrian’s big brother because it’s not a role he’s ever thought to assume. But Adrian clearly thinks of him that way to some degree: He admires Chris, idolizes him, would do anything for him, wants to believe he’s the person Chris confides in ahead of all others even when he’s not. We already know the mistakes Chris is making in choosing Emilia over Harcourt (and there’s a special kind of mind fuckery to be had in the fact that Chris can’t truly understand that they are <em>not</em> the same woman even if they look exactly alike), but Adrian’s pain lands differently because we haven’t been focused on his character enough this season to expect that hurt was coming.</p>
<p>Rick Flag Sr. is on a slight parallel of the journey Chris is going on; he claims that he beat Chris because he wants the guy to think he’s a liability, and that might be true after-the-fact, but that beating was from the heart. And Flag clearly didn’t get what he wanted from it. He wanted Chris to fight back, but yet again—you can’t control other people. You can only see to yourself.</p>
<p>Part of the issue here is that Chris is still trying to speedrun his own recovery from his father’s death. He knows he’s changed, but he hasn’t actually put in enough work yet, or given himself time to heal anything. Rather than realizing that’s part of the reason he’s running up against road blocks, he’s taking the quick and easy path out so he doesn’t have to feel how uncomfortable all that work is.</p>
<p>He has one true asset in all of this: an entire car of people who gear up to rescue him when he makes a stupid mistake. It’s the greatest asset any person can have, in fact. And Chris Smith about to find out why.</p>
<div style="height:10px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Keeping the Peace (Thoughts and Asides)</h3>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-4-1100x733.jpeg" alt="Economos looking anxious after booking Chris in Peacemaker's "Back to the Suture"" class="wp-image-824581" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-4-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-4-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-4-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-4-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/peacemaker-s2e5-4.jpeg 1920w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max</figcaption></figure>
<ul class="wp-block-list">
<li>Richard <em>Bill</em> Flag Jr.? Oh, yes. Thank you for that.</li>
</ul>
<ul class="wp-block-list">
<li>Okay, so the problem <em>is</em> that Harcourt considered Rick Jr. her best friend—but then I still don’t know why we needed them to sleep together to illustrate that. It’s like any time a man and a woman need to have a serious conversation on screen, it has to be a “morning after” one. The same thing is ultimate true for Harcourt and Chris here, too.</li>
</ul>
<ul class="wp-block-list">
<li>Regardless of how shitty Economos can be as a person, the comment about having a picture of Bordeaux’s mangled body as his phone screen falls on the other side of the Too Fucking Far line. Sometimes Gunn over-leans into those edgelord tendencies, and he sure hit it there.</li>
</ul>
<ul class="wp-block-list">
<li>Obviously, Bordeaux is playing Rick here (that <em>look</em> she gives him at the end of the episode), but the real question remains: Who is she working for? If you know the character’s comics background, there are some obvious options, but my real hope is Amanda Waller. (Bordeaux’s initial background as a Batman character is… absolutely no fun whatsoever, sorry.)</li>
</ul>
<ul class="wp-block-list">
<li>Even Fluery wasn’t feeling good about potential prisoner beatings—good to see the humanity start showing in the guy. (Though this episode did prompt my partner to look up the origin of the word “munchkin,” which was a fun Thursday night rabbit hole.)</li>
</ul>
<p>Back to the alt-reality next week, and I’m dreading it…[end-mark]</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/"><i>Peacemaker</i> Makes a Lot of Bad Decisions in “Back to the Suture”</a> appeared first on <a href="https://reactormag.com">Reactor</a>.</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/">https://reactormag.com/peacemaker-tv-review-back-to-the-suture/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824579">https://reactormag.com/?p=824579</a></p>
[Error: Irreparable invalid markup ('<a [...] w-[18px]>') in entry. Owner must fix manually. Raw contents below.]
<p class="syndicationauthor">Posted by Leah Schnelbach</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/">https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824539">https://reactormag.com/?p=824539</a></p><post-hero class="wp-block-post-hero js-post-hero post-hero post-hero-horizontal">
<div class="container container-desktop">
<div class="flex flex-col mx-auto post-hero-container">
<div class="post-hero-content">
<div class="post-hero-tags font-aktiv text-xs tracking-[0.5px] font-medium uppercase">
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/articles/movies-tv/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Movies & TV 0">
Movies & TV
</a>
</span>
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/tag/him/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Him 1">
Him
</a>
</span>
</div>
<h2 class="post-hero-title text-h1"><em>Him</em> Never Rises to GOAT Status</h2>
<div class="prose post-hero-description prose--post-hero">Him fumbles its journey to horror greatness.</div>
<div class="post-hero-wrapper">
<div class="post-hero-inner">
<p class="post-hero-author text-xs font-aktiv uppercase font-medium [&_a]:link-hover">By <a href="https://reactormag.com/author/leah-schnelbach/" title="Posts by Leah Schnelbach" class="author url fn" rel="author">Leah Schnelbach</a></p>
<span class="post-hero-symbol relative top-[-2px] hidden tablet:block">|</span>
<p class="text-xs uppercase post-hero-publish font-aktiv">
Published on September 19, 2025
</p>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-caption post-hero-caption-vertical [&_a]:link"><p>Credit: Universal Pictures</p>
</div>
<div class="quick-access post-hero-quick-access mt-[17px] tablet:hidden">
<div class="flex gap-[30px] tablet:gap-6">
<a href="https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/#comments" class="flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase translate-x-[1px] translate-y-[1px]">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 18 18" aria-label="comment" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-comment-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-comment-quick-access-">Comment</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<path fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" d="M6.3 18a.9.9 0 0 1-.9-.9v-2.7H1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 0 12.6V1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 1.8 0h14.4A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 18 1.8v10.8a1.8 1.8 0 0 1-1.8 1.8h-5.49l-3.33 3.339a.917.917 0 0 1-.63.261H6.3Z" />
<path stroke="#000" d="M5.9 14.4v-.5H1.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3-1.3V1.8A1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.8.5h14.4a1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.3 1.3v10.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3 1.3h-5.698l-.146.147-3.324 3.333a.417.417 0 0 1-.282.12H6.3a.4.4 0 0 1-.4-.4v-2.7Z" />
</g>
</svg>
0
</a>
<details class="relative quick-access-details">
<summary class="quick-access-share flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 22 22" aria-label="share" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-share-new-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-share-new-quick-access-">Share New</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="11" fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" />
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="10.5" stroke="#000" />
<path fill="#FFF" d="M5.993 13.464c.675 0 1.323-.266 1.806-.743l4.11 2.396a2.639 2.639 0 0 0 .368 2.451 2.583 2.583 0 0 0 2.227 1.043 2.59 2.59 0 0 0 2.09-1.3 2.64 2.64 0 0 0 .08-2.477 2.58 2.58 0 0 0-4.292-.54L8.344 11.94c.28-.616.31-1.319.086-1.958l3.952-2.303a2.564 2.564 0 0 0 4.263-.537 2.623 2.623 0 0 0-.078-2.46 2.573 2.573 0 0 0-2.075-1.293 2.566 2.566 0 0 0-2.213 1.033 2.622 2.622 0 0 0-.37 2.433L7.96 9.158a2.573 2.573 0 0 0-4.316.603 2.632 2.632 0 0 0 .172 2.501 2.58 2.58 0 0 0 2.178 1.202Z" />
<path fill="#000" d="M6.936 9.577c.322 0 .631.137.859.383.228.245.355.577.355.924 0 .347-.127.68-.355.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.859.383c-.322 0-.63-.138-.858-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.356-.925c0-.347.129-.679.356-.924.228-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm6.17-3.837c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.924 0 .347-.128.68-.356.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.924.227-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm0 7.883c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.925 0 .346-.128.679-.356.924a1.171 1.171 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.923.227-.245.536-.383.858-.384Zm-6.17-.681c.499 0 .978-.21 1.334-.586l3.036 1.888a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .272 1.93c.385.555 1.003.863 1.645.822.641-.04 1.221-.425 1.544-1.024a2.203 2.203 0 0 0 .059-1.952c-.286-.62-.841-1.044-1.48-1.13-.637-.085-1.272.18-1.69.705l-2.984-1.854c.207-.486.23-1.04.064-1.543l2.92-1.815c.415.522 1.046.784 1.68.7.633-.086 1.184-.507 1.468-1.123a2.188 2.188 0 0 0-.058-1.938c-.32-.595-.895-.977-1.532-1.018-.638-.041-1.251.264-1.635.813a2.179 2.179 0 0 0-.273 1.917L8.389 9.55c-.423-.534-1.07-.798-1.715-.702-.645.096-1.2.54-1.472 1.177a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .126 1.97c.352.59.958.948 1.61.947Z" />
</g>
</svg>
Share
</summary>
<div class="quick-access-bubble">
<ul class="flex gap-6 text-black list-none">
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=<em>Him</em> Never Rises to GOAT Status&url=https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/” target=”_blank” title=”Twitter”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[15px]"="h-[15px]"" width="18" height="15" viewbox="0 0 18 15" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="twitter" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/" target="_blank" title="Facebook">
<svg class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" fill="currentColor" viewbox="0 0 12 22" width="100%" height="100%" display="block" transitionduration="normal" transitionproperty="none" transitiontimingfunction="ease-out" class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" aria-label="facebook" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M11.558.004L8.677 0C5.44 0 3.349 2.125 3.349 5.416v2.496H.452A.45.45 0 000 8.36v3.618a.45.45 0 00.452.447h2.897v9.127A.45.45 0 003.8 22h3.778c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.448v-9.127h3.387c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.447l.003-3.618a.452.452 0 00-.456-.448h-3.39V5.795c0-1.017.245-1.534 1.582-1.534h1.941c.25 0 .452-.2.452-.447V.457a.45.45 0 00-.452-.448l.01-.005z" fill-rule="nonzero">
</path>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/&media=&description=<em>Him</em> Never Rises to GOAT Status” target=”_blank” title=”Pinterest”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[18px]"="h-[18px]"" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="pinterest" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://reactormag.com/feed/" target="_blank" title="RSS Feed">
<svg class="w-[17px] h-[17px]" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="rss feed" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<g clip-path="url(#clip0_1051_121783)">
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</g>
<defs>
<clippath id="clip0_1051_121783">
<rect width="17" height="17" fill="white" transform="translate(0.678711 0.414307)" />
</clippath>
</defs>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
</ul>
</div>
</details>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-media ">
<figure class="w-full h-auto post-hero-image">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="740" height="307" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/HIM-2-740x307.jpg" class="w-full object-cover" alt="Tyriq Withers in Him" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/HIM-2-740x307.jpg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/HIM-2-1100x456.jpg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/HIM-2-768x319.jpg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/HIM-2-1536x637.jpg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/HIM-2.jpg 1928w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 740px) 100vw, 740px" /> </figure>
<div class="post-hero-caption post-hero-caption-horizontal [&_a]:link"><p>Credit: Universal Pictures</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</post-hero>
<div class="wp-block-more-from-category">
<div>
</div>
</div>
<p>If you’ve seen <a href="https://reactormag.com/justin-tipping-him-trailer/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">the trailer</a> you know the plot: Isaiah White (Marlon Wayans) is America’s reigning GOAT quarterback. He plays with a team called The Saviors—and if that feels a little too obvious in its satire, well, this is not the movie for you. He was injured years ago but made a miraculous comeback, he’s played at a remarkable level for around 20 years, and as he hits middle age people have begun throwing the word “retirement” around more and more. Enter Cameron Cade (Tyriq Withers), the young up-and-comer, just out of college, ready to join The League. </p>
<p>We meet Cam as a little kid sitting in front of the TV watching Isaiah White’s terrible injury. We see his dad tell him that White is an example of what men do: they make sacrifices. No guts, no glory. And then dad hypes Cam up, telling him that he’ll replace White, and leading him in chants of “I’M HIM” and “IT’S MY TIME”.</p>
<p>The camera slides lovingly over the family’s various shrines to the Saviors, a football-themed Nativity scene, and images of its mascot—obviously a horned demonic monster. Did I mention that, in the game they watch, the opponents are The Masons?</p>
<p>Cam’s whole life has revolved around football since he was old enough to stand up. His mother, brother, and girlfriend all revolve around him like he’s the sun, and when he speaks, which isn’t often, it’s to say some variation of “I’m doing this for my family”. When a deranged fan smashes him in the head, it jeopardizes his world, and makes him helpless in the face of Isaiah Washington’s offer of a week-long private bootcamp.</p>
<p>Could there be more nefarious shit afoot(ball)?</p>
<p>I’ll counter that question with another question: have you ever seen a horror movie before?</p>
<p>The problem is that <em>Him </em>doesn’t quite know what kind of nefarious shit it wants to give its audience. Is this a dark satire about sports injuries like chronic traumatic encephalopathy? Sometimes! Is it a <em>wayyy</em> too on-the-nose exploration of hero worship that tips into religious ritual? You betcha! Is there a supernatural element? I think so!</p>
<p>No, no there <em>definitely</em> is—it’s just that it doesn’t commit to that hard enough to be the movie I hope for after seeing those first trailers. If a horror movie’s going to scream NO GUTS, NO GLORY at me, <em>I want to see the guts</em>.</p>
<p>I will say that Wayans and Withers act the shit out of their roles. Wayans gets to veer wildly between being a serious sports bro and something I can only described as “Hunter S. Thompson on Day 3 of the magazine profile”. And Withers layers real emotion under Cam’s mask of stoicism, I just wish the film had given him more to do. Julia Fox is perfect for the role of Isaiah’s wife/influencer, but, again, the script needed to give her more to do than her predictable arc of tempting Cam away from his training. And Tim Heidecker and Jim Jefferies are both great as Cam’s manager and Isaiah’s personal doctor, respectively—particularly Jefferies who gets to be the occasional, unexpected, voice of reason. Director Justin Tipping and Kira Kelly both make the film look fantastic. They create a post-MTV sheen that becomes creepier by the minute.</p>
<p>The problem, as I said, is that if you’ve ever seen a horror movie you know where <em>Him</em> is going, but rather than diving into footballs to the wall horror, gore, weirdness, <em>whatever</em>, it stays a sports movie with only hints of horroruntil the end. A lot of the frightening imagery could also be explained away as hallucinations brought on by Cam’s head injuries. There are moments that explore pro football’s extremely fucked up racial dynamics, but again, not quite enough. Cam is a cipher, but then he’s meant to be. He’s spent his entire short life repressing his actual thoughts and personality in order to pursue one goal. There are only two scenes where he’s really able to express himself, and both are effective—I just wish the film had leaned into them more. There is one scene that’s legitimately frightening—the one point where I heard people in the audience murmur and gasp—but it goes in a direction that’s more earthly and mundane than supernatural. And another moment that felt like a nod to <em>The Shining</em> that, again, cuts to Cam waking up in a daze rather than allowing a tone of genuine dread to build.</p>
<p><em>Him</em> hints at a dark mythology, but it never gets specific enough. There’s some “satanic” and “occult” imagery, there are knives, pentacles, animal skulls, blood sacrifices, and obviously the near-constant use of the word “goat”, but everyone also namechecks “God” the way athletes often do. Cam is often shirtless, and the camera zooms in on the chain and crucifix that bounce against his chest as his runs and lifts weights. Both pieces of jewelry are simple gold—he doesn’t wear the ostentatious diamonds that his brother and girlfriend flash at every light. He and Isaiah have a brief conversation about a trinity players often invoke—“God; Family; Football”—with Isaiah telling Cam that his version of it is “Football; Family; God”. Between that conversation and the near-constant crucifix close-ups, I thought the film would get into football as a cult that Cameron had to join, that there would be some sense of spiritual peril, but the movie never quite gets there, either.</p>
<p>There are rituals, and blood sacrifices, but we never <em>see</em> them except in a very quick-cut montage at a club late in the film. Even then, all we get is the aftermath, and some blurry shots that might be Cam’s hallucinations. The film repeatedly shows us something that might be scary, only to cut to Cam waking up in bed or an ice bath moments later. Which works once, sure, but not the five or six times it happens. As the situation gets weirder, Cam at times seems to roll with it, at other times to be freaked out. Then, abruptly, he acts like he’s determined to best Isaiah and replace him as QB—but he seems tentative and confused again a few scenes later. Then, out of nowhere, he wakes up ready to fight to the death for his career. Since the film doesn’t do enough work building the idea that Cam’s being seduced by some form of darkness or occult energy or anything, his emotional journey feels like its meeting the needs of the plot more than showing us more layers of his personality. Which is frustrating, again, because Withers is clearly trying to do that work.</p>
<p>I saw <em>Bull Durham</em> when I was a little kid, and one thing from the film that’s always stuck with me is the scene where Kevin Costner’s aging baseball player “Crash” Davis coaches Tim Robbins’ hotshot “Nuke” LaLoosh not through gameplay—Nuke’s got that pretty well covered—but through <em>media training</em>. Early in the film, we see Crash try to hammer it into Nuke’s head that he needs to act humble and cite the Lord when the cameras are pointed at him, and about an hour later, toward the end of the film, we see Nuke give an interview where he dutifully recites exactly what Crash told him to, with his head ducked shyly and everything. I remember that as a lightbulb moment for me, because I started to notice that most artists and athletes do a version of Crash’s humility act for the press. That might have been the moment that I realized that <em>everyone</em> is acting in public, whether they think about it or not.</p>
<p>Who are any of us, when the cameras aren’t on? Especially now, when the cameras are never off?</p>
<p>I think I wanted <em>Him </em>to lean more into the horror of <em>that</em>—the idea of giving yourself over to a corporation, to the public, offering yourself up as sacrifice until the “you” and the “self” is pretty much gone. I think that’s part of what the movie wanted to do, but I don’t think it went wild enough to say anything disturbing or new. If you want to be GOAT you have to dig deep.[end-mark]</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/"><em>Him</em> Never Rises to GOAT Status</a> appeared first on <a href="https://reactormag.com">Reactor</a>.</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/">https://reactormag.com/movie-review-him-justin-tipping/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824539">https://reactormag.com/?p=824539</a></p>
[Error: Irreparable invalid markup ('<a [...] w-[18px]>') in entry. Owner must fix manually. Raw contents below.]
<p class="syndicationauthor">Posted by Emmet Asher-Perrin</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/">https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824505">https://reactormag.com/?p=824505</a></p><post-hero class="wp-block-post-hero js-post-hero post-hero post-hero-horizontal">
<div class="container container-desktop">
<div class="flex flex-col mx-auto post-hero-container">
<div class="post-hero-content">
<div class="post-hero-tags font-aktiv text-xs tracking-[0.5px] font-medium uppercase">
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/articles/movies-tv/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Movies & TV 0">
Movies & TV
</a>
</span>
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/tag/gen-v/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Gen V 1">
Gen V
</a>
</span>
</div>
<h2 class="post-hero-title text-h1"><i>Gen V</i> Goes Back to Supes School With Season 2 Reset</h2>
<div class="prose post-hero-description prose--post-hero">With the death of a lead series actor, Gen V has a lot of ground to cover in its second season premiere.</div>
<div class="post-hero-wrapper">
<div class="post-hero-inner">
<p class="post-hero-author text-xs font-aktiv uppercase font-medium [&_a]:link-hover">By <a href="https://reactormag.com/author/ben-francisco/" title="Posts by Ben Francisco" class="author url fn" rel="author">Ben Francisco</a></p>
<span class="post-hero-symbol relative top-[-2px] hidden tablet:block">|</span>
<p class="text-xs uppercase post-hero-publish font-aktiv">
Published on September 19, 2025
</p>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-caption post-hero-caption-vertical [&_a]:link"><p>Credit: Jasper Savage/Prime Video</p>
</div>
<div class="quick-access post-hero-quick-access mt-[17px] tablet:hidden">
<div class="flex gap-[30px] tablet:gap-6">
<a href="https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/#comments" class="flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase translate-x-[1px] translate-y-[1px]">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 18 18" aria-label="comment" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-comment-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-comment-quick-access-">Comment</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<path fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" d="M6.3 18a.9.9 0 0 1-.9-.9v-2.7H1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 0 12.6V1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 1.8 0h14.4A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 18 1.8v10.8a1.8 1.8 0 0 1-1.8 1.8h-5.49l-3.33 3.339a.917.917 0 0 1-.63.261H6.3Z" />
<path stroke="#000" d="M5.9 14.4v-.5H1.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3-1.3V1.8A1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.8.5h14.4a1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.3 1.3v10.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3 1.3h-5.698l-.146.147-3.324 3.333a.417.417 0 0 1-.282.12H6.3a.4.4 0 0 1-.4-.4v-2.7Z" />
</g>
</svg>
0
</a>
<details class="relative quick-access-details">
<summary class="quick-access-share flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 22 22" aria-label="share" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-share-new-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-share-new-quick-access-">Share New</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="11" fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" />
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="10.5" stroke="#000" />
<path fill="#FFF" d="M5.993 13.464c.675 0 1.323-.266 1.806-.743l4.11 2.396a2.639 2.639 0 0 0 .368 2.451 2.583 2.583 0 0 0 2.227 1.043 2.59 2.59 0 0 0 2.09-1.3 2.64 2.64 0 0 0 .08-2.477 2.58 2.58 0 0 0-4.292-.54L8.344 11.94c.28-.616.31-1.319.086-1.958l3.952-2.303a2.564 2.564 0 0 0 4.263-.537 2.623 2.623 0 0 0-.078-2.46 2.573 2.573 0 0 0-2.075-1.293 2.566 2.566 0 0 0-2.213 1.033 2.622 2.622 0 0 0-.37 2.433L7.96 9.158a2.573 2.573 0 0 0-4.316.603 2.632 2.632 0 0 0 .172 2.501 2.58 2.58 0 0 0 2.178 1.202Z" />
<path fill="#000" d="M6.936 9.577c.322 0 .631.137.859.383.228.245.355.577.355.924 0 .347-.127.68-.355.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.859.383c-.322 0-.63-.138-.858-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.356-.925c0-.347.129-.679.356-.924.228-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm6.17-3.837c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.924 0 .347-.128.68-.356.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.924.227-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm0 7.883c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.925 0 .346-.128.679-.356.924a1.171 1.171 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.923.227-.245.536-.383.858-.384Zm-6.17-.681c.499 0 .978-.21 1.334-.586l3.036 1.888a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .272 1.93c.385.555 1.003.863 1.645.822.641-.04 1.221-.425 1.544-1.024a2.203 2.203 0 0 0 .059-1.952c-.286-.62-.841-1.044-1.48-1.13-.637-.085-1.272.18-1.69.705l-2.984-1.854c.207-.486.23-1.04.064-1.543l2.92-1.815c.415.522 1.046.784 1.68.7.633-.086 1.184-.507 1.468-1.123a2.188 2.188 0 0 0-.058-1.938c-.32-.595-.895-.977-1.532-1.018-.638-.041-1.251.264-1.635.813a2.179 2.179 0 0 0-.273 1.917L8.389 9.55c-.423-.534-1.07-.798-1.715-.702-.645.096-1.2.54-1.472 1.177a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .126 1.97c.352.59.958.948 1.61.947Z" />
</g>
</svg>
Share
</summary>
<div class="quick-access-bubble">
<ul class="flex gap-6 text-black list-none">
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=<i>Gen V</i> Goes Back to Supes School With Season 2 Reset&url=https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/” target=”_blank” title=”Twitter”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[15px]"="h-[15px]"" width="18" height="15" viewbox="0 0 18 15" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="twitter" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/" target="_blank" title="Facebook">
<svg class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" fill="currentColor" viewbox="0 0 12 22" width="100%" height="100%" display="block" transitionduration="normal" transitionproperty="none" transitiontimingfunction="ease-out" class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" aria-label="facebook" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M11.558.004L8.677 0C5.44 0 3.349 2.125 3.349 5.416v2.496H.452A.45.45 0 000 8.36v3.618a.45.45 0 00.452.447h2.897v9.127A.45.45 0 003.8 22h3.778c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.448v-9.127h3.387c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.447l.003-3.618a.452.452 0 00-.456-.448h-3.39V5.795c0-1.017.245-1.534 1.582-1.534h1.941c.25 0 .452-.2.452-.447V.457a.45.45 0 00-.452-.448l.01-.005z" fill-rule="nonzero">
</path>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/&media=&description=<i>Gen V</i> Goes Back to Supes School With Season 2 Reset” target=”_blank” title=”Pinterest”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[18px]"="h-[18px]"" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="pinterest" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://reactormag.com/feed/" target="_blank" title="RSS Feed">
<svg class="w-[17px] h-[17px]" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="rss feed" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<g clip-path="url(#clip0_1051_121783)">
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</g>
<defs>
<clippath id="clip0_1051_121783">
<rect width="17" height="17" fill="white" transform="translate(0.678711 0.414307)" />
</clippath>
</defs>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
</ul>
</div>
</details>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-media ">
<figure class="w-full h-auto post-hero-image">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="740" height="493" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-1-740x493.jpeg" class="w-full object-cover" alt="Jaz Sinclair (Marie Moreau) in an arena in Gen V S3 premiere" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-1-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-1-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-1-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-1-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-1-2048x1366.jpeg 2048w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 740px) 100vw, 740px" /> </figure>
<div class="post-hero-caption post-hero-caption-horizontal [&_a]:link"><p>Credit: Jasper Savage/Prime Video</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</post-hero>
<div class="wp-block-more-from-category">
<div>
</div>
</div>
<p><em>Gen V</em> has returned with its three-episode premiere of season two, nearly two years after the first season reached its cliffhanger conclusion. That’s not an exceptionally long gap for the streaming era, but production was delayed by the unexpected and tragic death of Chance Perdomo, who played the magnetically powered Andre. Rather than recast the role, the producers rewrote the storyline around the character’s death, making these opening episodes something of a homage to both Perdomo and the character he played. </p>
<div style="height:10px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<h3 class="wp-block-heading"><strong>“New Year, New U”</strong></h3>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-4-1100x733.jpeg" alt="Jaz Sinclair (Marie Moreau), Hamish Linklater (Dean Cipher) in a confrontation in Gen V S3 premiere" class="wp-image-824514" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-4-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-4-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-4-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-4-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-4-2048x1366.jpeg 2048w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Credit: Jasper Savage/Prime Video</figcaption></figure>
<p>The season begins with a flashback to 1967 in a laboratory labelled “Odessa Project.” Five white men in suits and lab coats inject themselves with a serum and immediately suffer gruesome side effects ranging from exploding intestines to catching on fire. A sixth man, who turns out to be Dr. Godolkin himself (Vought scientist and founder of Godolkin University), tries to stop them from taking the not-ready serum but ultimately seems to get consumed by the fire along with the rest.</p>
<p>Back in the present day, size-changing Emma (Lizza Broadway) and energy-blasting and gender-shifting Jordan (Derek Luh and London Thor) are violently trucked out of the prison where they’ve been languishing since last season. They’re surprised to find themselves back at Godolkin University, greeted by Cate (Maddie Phillips), the last person they want to see after her betrayal last season. Cate scans their minds with her telepathic powers and is shocked to learn that Andre died in captivity. Emma and Jordan learn that their release comes with conditions: they have to tow the latest Vought propaganda about supe superiority, starting with a press conference for the whole school and close-ups for the cameras. </p>
<p>Cate confronts Cipher, the mysteriously super-abled new dean of Godolkin University (deftly played by Hamish Linklater), and demands to know how Andre died. He displays an impressive capacity to avoid her mental control and reminds her she has to find Marie Moreau (Jaz Sinclair). </p>
<p>Marie, who somehow escaped from prison between seasons, is on the run, living off convenience store snacks and motels as she searches for her sister. With the country more violently divided than ever after the events of the last season of <em>The Boys</em>, a gang of fascist Hometeamers attacks a group of pro-freedom Starlighters. Marie uses her blood-controlling powers to rescue them – but is caught on video, tipping off Vought to her location. Following her scent from a bag of chips, the bounty hunter Dogknott tracks her down to her motel and nearly subdues her – but is stopped by Starlight (Erin Moriarty), hero of the resistance amidst Homelander’s rising super-fascist regime.</p>
<p>Starlight asks Marie to accept the same Faustian bargain as her friends did and go back to Godolkin to find out more about “Project Odessa,” which she says is a weapons program that’s recently resumed its research.</p>
<p>At a party back at school, Emma has a difficult conversation with Sam (Asa Germann), her super-strong former love interest turned fascist sympathizer. She gets so distraught she shrinks—a new twist on her size-shifting powers. After a game of beer pong with tiny Emma as the ping pong ball, she sees the video footage of Marie. Emma and Jordan Uber off to find their friend.</p>
<p>The three heroes are reunited outside the convenience store. Jordan confronts Marie about abandoning them in prison—and tells her that Andre died trying to escape after she did. Before Marie can process the sad news, Cate appears. With her telepathy, Cate clocks Marie’s secret conversation with Starlight about Odessa. Cate tries to take control of Marie, but Jordan blocks her with an energy blast, knocking her into a wall and leaving her bleeding from the skull.</p>
<div style="height:10px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<h3 class="wp-block-heading"><strong>“Justice Never Forgets”</strong></h3>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-2-1100x733.jpeg" alt="Maddie Phillips (Cate Dunlap) standing in the front of crowd in Gen V S3 premiere" class="wp-image-824516" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-2-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-2-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-2-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-2-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-2-2048x1366.jpeg 2048w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Credit: Jasper Savage/Prime Video</figcaption></figure>
<p>The second episode opens with Marie awkwardly (and humorously) recording a TikTok-style video about her mental health healing journey bringing her back to Godolkin University. Emma, who’s directing the video, reasons that the more public they are the safer they’ll be. But it’s clear that Emma, Marie, and Jordan are not yet on the same page, and Jordan in particular still has sore feelings about Marie leaving them behind.</p>
<p>The TikTok gambit works, and Marie meets with Dean Cipher about returning to school. He reveals he knows she saw him working at the Elmira detention facility but seems unconcerned about it. He drops the further bombshell that Andre had been suffering from the same illness as his father, and likely knew his attempted escape would cost him his life.</p>
<p>Cate has survived her head injury but remains unconscious in the hospital. When Sam visits her there, her powers go haywire, as she says the name “Emma” through a nurse and causes hospital employees to attack each other.</p>
<p>In a new “hero optimization seminary,” Dean Cipher pushes Jordan, Marie, and other students to level up their powers through a series of trials by combat that don’t seem to have any safety protocols. Jordan and Marie save each other from a hammer-wielding attacker, then go back to the dorm to process their grief and anger over imprisonment and the loss of Andre. As they kiss, Marie assuages Jordan’s doubts by saying, “Anything and everything you do is okay,” affirming her affection for both of Jordan’s gender identities. She also says “I love you” for the first time, which Jordan awkwardly does not reciprocate.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, Andre’s father, Polarity, has realized that the best way to honor his son’s legacy is to investigate Dean Cipher and the Odessa Project. He and Emma team up and charm their way into Thomas Godolkin’s archives. Despite Emma accidentally rolling on Molly, they find a secret room stocked with Godolkin’s disturbing collection of Nazi paraphernalia—and the Odessa files. Emma’s excitement at the discovery causes her to grow to giant size—for the first time without having to eat.</p>
<p>Vought’s corporate propaganda machine pins Cate’s injury on an innocent Starlighter, leading to celebrations of supe supremacy and chants of “fuck humans” across campus. Amidst the fireworks and revelry, Emma shows Jordan the secret she’s uncovered: Marie <em>is</em> Odessa.</p>
<p>Back in the hospital, Cate wakes up, surrounded by the bloody bodies of several medical staff. Enter Dean Cipher, who is characteristically nonplussed.</p>
<div style="height:10px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<h3 class="wp-block-heading"><strong>“H is for Human”</strong></h3>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-5-1100x733.jpeg" alt="an image of Ethan Slater's (Thomas Godolkin) work badge in Gen V S3 premiere" class="wp-image-824513" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-5-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-5-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-5-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-5-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-5-2048x1366.jpeg 2048w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Credit: Jasper Savage/Prime Video</figcaption></figure>
<p>We follow a university cafe employee as she goes through the humiliating paces of entering the university as a human: wearing an “H” identification card, entering the “Human entrance,” and enduring an X-ray vision scan by a prurient super-abled security guard. </p>
<p>At Polarity’s home, our heroes puzzle over the Odessa revelation. Why did Starlight recruit Marie to uncover Odessa if she <em>is</em> Odessa? Is Marie a weapon? Marie resists the idea of being a “chosen one,” a role she ascribes to “baby-faced white dudes” like Harry Potter, Neo, and “fucking Frodo.” She resolves to learn more about Odessa from her aunt Pam, a long-lost family friend who’s in a baby photo of Marie that they found in the Odessa files. </p>
<p>Cate returns to campus, greeted with cheers and smiles by Hometeamers and the head of student life. In the power optimization seminar, Marie overcomes another opponent, but Dean Cipher presses her on why she cuts herself to gain access to her powers, saying she’s capable of much more than she knows.</p>
<p>In Cate’s absence, Sam’s hallucinations are returning, since he can no longer rely on her mental pushes to eliminate them and more generally flatten his feelings. He goes to Cate to ask her to do it again, but she can’t since her powers are on the fritz.</p>
<p>Frustrated, Sam trashes a dorm room. Jordan intervenes and they battle, leaving a trail of smashed walls throughout the dormitory. Eventually, they shift from punching to talking, and bond over their shared love for Sam’s deceased brother. “There’s been enough death,” Jordan says.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, Emma goes for muffins at the cafe, where she encounters the human from the episode’s opening sequence. Someone puts up a Starlighter flier at super-speed, a recurring problem for the human employee, who repeatedly gets assaulted by anti-human students who blame her for the fliers. Emma lets her know that “some of us actually do give a shit.” She chases the supe and loses them in the boy’s locker room, but tracks them down later, leading her to a duo of students who engage in small acts of vandalism in protest of Homelander’s fascist agenda. Emma gives a speech encouraging them to do more, implicitly invoking Andre’s legacy of moving others to find their own heroism.</p>
<p>Marie visits Aunt Pam. After some awkward moments, Pam shows her a stack of old photos—including one of Dean Cipher holding Marie as a baby. He’s also known as Doctor Gold, the doctor who delivered Marie. But things get even more awkward when Marie stumbles into a bedroom that once belonged to her little sister. Marie demands to talk to her sister, but Pam says she doesn’t want anything to do with her. </p>
<p>Jordan and Sam continue their bonding, watching the children’s show “Avenue V,” getting stoned, and talking about the friends they’ve lost. Jordan realizes that you never know when you might lose the chance to tell someone you love them.</p>
<p>As the entire campus gathers to celebrate Thomas Godolkin Day, Jordan finally tells Marie they love her too. Dean Cipher announces that Jordan is the new number one in Godolkin’s student rankings and calls them up to give a speech. At first, Jordan delivers the Vought-scripted propaganda about Godolkin University being “trans-tastic,” but stops. Shifting to their female form, they reveal that Andre died in prison, heroically trying to free his friends. Then Jordan confesses to being the one who attacked Cate – and is met by jeers from the increasingly supe-supremacist Godolkin student body. </p>
<div style="height:10px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<h3 class="wp-block-heading"><strong>Commentary</strong></h3>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-3-1100x733.jpeg" alt="Jaz Sinclair (Marie Moreau), London Thor (Jordan Li) with foreheads pressed together in Gen V S3 premiere" class="wp-image-824515" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-3-1100x733.jpeg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-3-740x493.jpeg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-3-768x512.jpeg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-3-1536x1024.jpeg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/genv-s3-premiere-3-2048x1365.jpeg 2048w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Credit: Prime Video</figcaption></figure>
<p>These three episodes have a lot of work to do: setting up the transition from one season to the next while also covering some backstory from the most recent season of <em>The Boys</em>—and explaining the disappearance of Andre in a way that fits the story and gracefully honors the legacy of the character and of Chance Perdomo.</p>
<p>The show largely manages to fulfill that tall order. It’s especially effective when Cate learns how Andre died by reading Jordan’s mind, a speculative variation on the disorientation and chaotic absorption of information that so often comes after a death. Throughout all three episodes, various characters pay tribute to Andre’s heroic death, but the most powerful moments come when the writers allow the story to lean into the complexity of grief, with characters experiencing not only sadness but also anger and blame, with themselves and with each other. The leading actors all give strong performances here, and it’s easy to imagine that some of the more tearful moments drew on real-life sadness over the unexpected loss of Perdomo.</p>
<p>While Andre’s death is handled as deftly as possible, some of the other transitions to the status quo of the new season feel more abrupt. It’s still not clear how Marie escaped a high-security prison, and even less clear why she is searching desperately for her sister but so easily gave up on her best friends and former love interest, all wasting away in a cell. (Jordan’s anger about that issue seems pretty reasonable to me!) </p>
<p>More generally, the fast shift from being imprisoned to a full reset of the kids being back at school feels forced, more at the service of the plot than an organic evolution. That said, the writers manage to convert even that flaw into a strength. A string of awkward press conferences and social media moments highlights just how jarring it is for the characters to go back to the school that imprisoned them – to disturbing and hilarious effects.</p>
<p>Linklater is an excellent addition to the cast, with a subdued portrayal of Dean Cipher that’s just the right balance of mysterious, creepy, and intimidating—always seeming to know more than he’s letting on. I’m not sure whether his power is some sort of omniperception or if he just has a Batman-like ability to plan for everything, but either way I’m here for it.</p>
<p>Jordan continues to be a stand-out character for me, with Derek Luh and London Thor both playing the character skillfully. (I’m so curious what their collaborative creative process is like to jointly depict the character!) They feel slightly more integrated this season than last, when, as Marie noted, Jordan would routinely shift to their male form any time they wanted other people to pay attention. I was glad to see the rebuilding of trust between Jordan and Marie, and the moment when Marie affirms the fullness of Jordan’s gender identity is one of the sweetest in the show’s run. In contrast, Godolkin University’s self-promotion of how trans-affirming they are, after the institution consistently has repressed Jordan’s bigender identity, was disturbingly true to life. </p>
<p>This season of <em>Gen V</em>, like its parent show <em>The Boys</em>, leans even more heavily into the themes of rising fascism and “supe supremacy.” Given the state of the world, there are times where it’s almost uncomfortably accurate, especially the way that the vast majority of students have so enthusiastically embraced Homelander’s fascist regime and casual re-writing of history. But that also makes it resonate all the more, particularly as our heroes try to find ways to fight back, love each other, and simply live their lives amidst such a horrific context.</p>
<p>For the most part, the shared continuity with <em>The Boys</em> offers an additional layer for those who watch both shows. As with the first season, <em>Gen V</em> offers a more ground-level view of this world, with details like a segregated back-entrance for humans hinting at just how bad things have gotten since Homelander basically took over everything at the end of season four of <em>The Boys</em>. Guest appearances like the frat ritual facilitated by Godolkin alum the Deep (Chace Crawdord) provide occasional fun and amusing Easter eggs. Other crossover moments, like Starlight’s appearance in episode one to provide Marie with “her assignment,” feel a bit more forced. But hopefully that balance will work out over the course of the season.</p>
<p>Being in the world of <em>The Boys</em>, blood-spurting violence and nude scenes abound. Some of these, like the hero optimization seminar battles, feel like they advance the story, while others seem a bit extraneous. Your mileage may vary.</p>
<p>Twice, the head of student life has pointed out that her bee-like stinger would leave both her and its victim brutally dead, a Chekov’s gun that will undoubtedly go off at some point this season, hopefully in a way that does something useful for plot or character development.</p>
<p>The storyline around Project Odessa and Marie honing her powers brought me a little bit of geeky joy. She shares her blood-controlling power with Victoria Neuman, the Vice President Elect who died in the season finale of <em>The Boys</em>. Neuman had been set up to be one of the most powerful supers of this universe, using her ability to control not only the blood in her own body, but in others as well, with devastating effects. I’d been a little disappointed her character had been eliminated, and am interested to see them continue exploring the many possibilities of blood-control powers through Marie.</p>
<p>Let’s see where the rest of the season takes us![end-mark]</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/"><i>Gen V</i> Goes Back to Supes School With Season 2 Reset</a> appeared first on <a href="https://reactormag.com">Reactor</a>.</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/">https://reactormag.com/tv-review-gen-v-season-2-premiere/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824505">https://reactormag.com/?p=824505</a></p>
At 4.3 light years1, Alpha Centauri is currently the closest star system to our own2. Alpha Centauri is a triplet star system, whose most distant component, Alpha Centauri C, is small, dim, distant from its two companions3, and irrelevant to this essay. Alpha Centauri A (whose proposed world is the subject of this essay) is slightly more massive than the Sun and half again as bright. B is a little less massive than the Sun and half as bright. A and B have an eccentric orbit around each other4, but not so closely as to preclude planets in either star’s habitable zone5. At least not directly.
Because Alpha Centauri is nearby, because two of its components are Sun-like, and because SF authors have heard of the star system, SF authors have populated A and B with many habitable planets, some of which I’ve mentioned in an earlier essay6.
Alas, nothing known about the exoplanet Alpha Centauri Ab (A is the star, b is the planet) suggests that it’s habitable. To begin with the minor issues, Ab is actually a bit outside A’s habitable zone, thus its estimated temperature of 225 K or about -50o C. Not necessarily a deal-killer. The estimate excludes, as far as I can tell, the impact of any greenhouse gases. As you know (Bob) without its atmosphere, Earth would be about 255 K or about -25o C7.
The next issue is that Ab’s orbit is far more eccentric than that of Earth; it’s comparable to Pluto’s. This means the amount of light Ab receives from A varies considerably over the course of a single orbit. Ab spends a lot more time traversing the outer part of its orbit than it does the inner8. So, longer, colder winters than Earth and because the issue is distance and not axial tilt, all of Ab goes into the deep freeze at the same time. No migrating to the summertime hemisphere.
This paper observes that “The S1+C1 candidate is in a highly inclined (≈50∘ or ≈130∘ with respect to the α Cen AB binary orbital plane) and eccentric (∼0.4) orbit, not unlike other S-type planets in close binary systems (e.g., HD 196885 Ab and γ Cep Ab), and is expected to undergo large amplitude von Zeipel-Kozai-Lidov (vZKL) oscillations.”
This isn’t great, because it means that the eccentricity isn’t just extreme, but evolving.
All of which is minor compared to the final detail: Ab is somewhat more massive than Saturn, which means it’s probably composed of hydrogen and helium. Maybe it’s an extremely large ice giant (ice giants are worlds like Neptune or Uranus, which have a significant amount of water, in states of matter unlike any with which we’re familiar) but probably not. In any case, Ab would be as uninhabitable as our Solar System’s gas or ice giants.
Ab’s mass has another annoying consequence, which is that it’s clearing out adjacent orbits that might otherwise (assuming a multitude of counterfactuals) be taken by an Earth-massed planet.
Perhaps Ab has Mars-plus massed moons and maybe one or more of them is a potential abode for life?
The first thing that comes to mind is that no gas or ice giant in our system has moons quite that large in comparison to the primary. Still, if there’s one thing exoplanets have taught us, it is that our solar system is not the default model. Yet… even if such an Earth-like moon existed it would be subject to the very un-Earthlike conditions mentioned above.
Ah, well. There’s always Alpha Centauri B… except that if B is large enough for to induce von Zeipel-Kozai-Lidov oscillations in Ab, then surely the more massive A will do the same for any hypothetical Bb?
There are a lot more ways for a world to be uninhabitable than habitable, so it’s not that surprising9 that Alpha Centauri Ab seems to be a dud from that angle. It’s still an interesting system from an orbital dynamics perspective, but for habitable worlds, we will have to look elsewhere.[end-mark]
That is about the height of 10^16 giraffes, stacked one on top of each other, and ignoring that such a mass of giraffes would collapse into an extremely (if only very briefly) distressed sphere. Yes, obviously the giraffes are in space suits. I’m not a monster. ︎
C is almost 9000 times as far from AB as the Earth is from the Sun. I too am boggled that the star has not been stripped away from AB over the five billion plus years the system has been around. By the way, case matters. If I say A or B, I mean the stars but a lower-case b is an exoplanet. AB would be both Alpha Centauri A and B, but Ab would be the proposed planet orbiting A and Bb an exoplanet orbiting B. ︎
The distance between A and B varies from about the distance between the Sun and Neptune and the Sun and Jupiter. ︎
Or sometimes, in the case of authors who knew the name but nothing else about Alpha Centauri, the planet orbiting a singleton star called Alpha Centauri. ︎
Back when the Sun was young, it was much dimmer than it is now. A back of the envelope calculation says the Earth, other factors aside, would have had about the same temperature as Alpha Centauri Ab. Why everything wasn’t frozen solid is a bit of a mystery. Alpha Centauri A being more massive than the Sun, its luminosity would have evolved even more and faster than the Sun’s. Ab might have been even farther from the habitable zone than it is today… except we know the orbit would have been very different billions of years ago. ︎
Because A and B’s orbit around each other is eccentric, climate on Ab would be further complicated by B’s small but not negligible input as it varies over an eighty-year cycle. ︎
What is astonishing, at least to me, is the number of red dwarfs, such as Alpha Centauri C, that have exoplanets in their Goldilocks zone. Red dwarfs are very dim and their potentially habitable zones are tiny. Is there something that favours planetary formation in or near that region of stellar systems? ︎
The first day of fall is Monday. I’m really sorry to bring this up—unless, of course, you’re one of the people for whom this is very welcome news. (How about both? Can I be both?) In Portland, we’re in that stretch of time where leaves might fall into your drinks when you’re sitting outside enjoying the high-70s perfect weather. It’s crossover season. Unintentionally, this week’s recommendations are a little crossover-y, too: sports and horror, books and architecture, satisfying and unsatisfying versions of a similar plot. And Brian Eno, who crosses over most things, come to think of it. Settle in with your beverage of choice, and don’t forget to call your reps.
Okay, so, the reviews for Justin Tipping’s football horror movie Him are far from glowing. “Style to burn and not much else,” says Vulture’s headline. But I still want to watch it. Honestly, this movie deserves my time just for the gory beauty of its first teaser. It’s 10,000 percent a sports ad (“If you want to transcend the game, you have to dig deep”)—one that goes absolutely haywire. And the effectiveness of that trailer choice made me think about bodies, and sports, and all the ways that a body, put through great physical stress, can go haywire in all kinds of “normal” ways. Bodies are weird, no? At least, if you think about them too much. Anyway. I grew up in the kind of small American town where there is so little to do that everyone goes to the high school football game, even if they—like me—have zero interest in football. I’ve seen the clichés. I want to see the actually-making-it-weird version. But it might not be great. Is it worth it? You can only do that math for yourself.
Just Look at the Pretty Books as a Palate Cleanser
I don’t even remember where this link came from, because it erased all the thoughts in my mind when I clicked it. (Bliss, for a half a second.) “57 brilliant bookshelf ideas for every type of space,” a post from the UK’s House & Garden, requires nothing of you. You can just scroll and admire bookcases. Bookshelves. Beautifully arranged books in tasteful houses. There is, I admit, a preponderance of beige and white walls, and not as much artful chaos as some may wish for. (There is some, though, like the shelves with art hanging on the front of them.) There is a green book nook that I would very much like to read in. There’s a gorgeous cat on a red sofa in a room with red shelves and colorful rugs. There’s so much. I am only halfway through and saving the rest for later.
Which Older Fantasy Books Meet Modern Expectations?
My favorite online discussion this week was definitely the conversation Eddie Clark started when he asked, “what 80s & 90s epic fantasy holds up best to modern eyes and why?”
I am constantly wishing I had more time to go back and read my old favorites—partly because I want to see what does hold up, and partly because I want to see how differently I might feel or think about those books now. The answers to Clark’s question vary, though there is a lot of agreement on Robin Hobb’s Realm of the Elderlings series (serieses?) and quite a few mentions of Kate Elliott, Melanie Rawn (specifically her Exiles series), and Janny Wurts. We can nitpick about whether Tamora Pierce’s books are epic fantasy or not—and there are several similar arguments in the thread!—but I just read Alanna: The First Adventure this week and it was such a joy that I got mad at myself for not having the next three books to hand. There are a few things to quibble with, but Alanna’s fear and frustration and determination are just perfectly depicted.
What holds up for you? What do you want to reread? Is fall the perfect time to do just that?
I’m Going to Go Have a Good Cry with The Magicians
I was not alone in finding the just-ended season of Strange New Worldsunderwhelming. The humor wasn’t as sharp as it needed to be; the characters didn’t get enough focus or time to develop; and the finale asked us to be deeply invested in a relationship that’s never quite clicked (and I’m still not over all the unfortunate bioessentialism). But a certain part of the season finale—if you’ve seen it, you know—reminded me of one of my favorite episodes of television of all time: The Magicians’ “A Life in the Day.” In the midst of a quest for some magic keys, Quentin and Eliot wind up living out a whole life while trying to solve a mosaic puzzle. That’s the meat of it. And just thinking about that episode makes me a little teary. It’s beautiful, and in the big picture of the show, it’s meaningful. It also comes at a point when we know these characters, their flaws and foibles and big cracked hearts. It makes sense; it builds things, and it undoes things. And if you would like a good cathartic cry, it will probably give you that.
Wanna Watch a Movie You Can Never See the Same Way Twice?
Please forgive me, because I’m about to talk about a movie you probably can’t actually watch right now (though it is coming to streaming eventually!). But the thing is, you should know about this movie so that you can watch it when it is available to you—and then maybe watch it again, because the odds of it appearing the same way twice are infinitesimal. I’m talking about Eno, the documentary about Brian Eno, for which director Gary Hustwit “and creative technologist Brendan Dawes have developed bespoke generative software designed to sequence scenes and create transitions out of Hustwit’s original interviews with Eno, and Eno’s rich archive of hundreds of hours of never-before-seen footage, and unreleased music.” (You can read more about the creation of the film at The Verge.)
Listen: Maybe you think you don’t care about Brian Eno. Fair enough. But if you care about art, and creativity, and the creation of some of the last century’s most enduring music; if you care about how people move through the world and make art and keep being curious; if you could use a straight shot of hope—well, then you should watch this movie when you can. The critic Carl Wilson watched it (almost) five times in a row, and wrote, “It was replenishing because while it lasted, Brian Eno made it seem possible to be hopeful without being oblivious or gullible.”
If you would like to watch a music documentary now, though, may I also suggest the wonderfully chaotic Pavements, which also takes a variety of approaches to its material (though not quite as many as Eno). I cannot emphasize strongly enough the excellence of 20 Feet from Stardom, a documentary that gives backup singers like Darlene Love and Merry Clayton their due (seriously, you will never listen to “Gimme Shelter” the same way again).
On Sunday, Lilith Fair: Building a Mystery—The Untold Story hits Hulu, and I can’t wait. (This oral history of the Fair can tide you over until the premiere.) One of the producers on Lilith Fair is critic Jessica Hopper, who also directed the excellent series Women Who Rock. You should watch that, too. If you like good things.[end-mark]
[Error: Irreparable invalid markup ('<a [...] h-[15px]">') in entry. Owner must fix manually. Raw contents below.]
<p class="syndicationauthor">Posted by Christina Orlando</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/">https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824072">https://reactormag.com/?p=824072</a></p><post-hero class="wp-block-post-hero js-post-hero post-hero post-hero-vertical">
<div class="container container-desktop">
<div class="flex flex-col mx-auto post-hero-container">
<div class="post-hero-content">
<div class="post-hero-tags font-aktiv text-xs tracking-[0.5px] font-medium uppercase">
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/articles/books/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Books 0">
Books
</a>
</span>
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/tag/book-reviews/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag book reviews 1">
book reviews
</a>
</span>
</div>
<h2 class="post-hero-title text-h1">Andrew Joseph White’s <i>You Weren’t Meant to Be Human</i> Pushes a Lot of Buttons</h2>
<div class="prose post-hero-description prose--post-hero">Alex Brown doesn’t chicken out of Andrew Joseph White’s intense first novel for adults.</div>
<div class="post-hero-wrapper">
<div class="post-hero-inner">
<p class="post-hero-author text-xs font-aktiv uppercase font-medium [&_a]:link-hover">By <a href="https://reactormag.com/author/alex-brown/" title="Posts by Alex Brown" class="author url fn" rel="author">Alex Brown</a></p>
<span class="post-hero-symbol relative top-[-2px] hidden tablet:block">|</span>
<p class="text-xs uppercase post-hero-publish font-aktiv">
Published on September 18, 2025
</p>
</div>
</div>
<div class="quick-access post-hero-quick-access mt-[17px] tablet:hidden">
<div class="flex gap-[30px] tablet:gap-6">
<a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/#comments" class="flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase translate-x-[1px] translate-y-[1px]">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 18 18" aria-label="comment" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-comment-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-comment-quick-access-">Comment</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<path fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" d="M6.3 18a.9.9 0 0 1-.9-.9v-2.7H1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 0 12.6V1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 1.8 0h14.4A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 18 1.8v10.8a1.8 1.8 0 0 1-1.8 1.8h-5.49l-3.33 3.339a.917.917 0 0 1-.63.261H6.3Z" />
<path stroke="#000" d="M5.9 14.4v-.5H1.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3-1.3V1.8A1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.8.5h14.4a1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.3 1.3v10.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3 1.3h-5.698l-.146.147-3.324 3.333a.417.417 0 0 1-.282.12H6.3a.4.4 0 0 1-.4-.4v-2.7Z" />
</g>
</svg>
0
</a>
<details class="relative quick-access-details">
<summary class="quick-access-share flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 22 22" aria-label="share" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-share-new-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-share-new-quick-access-">Share New</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="11" fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" />
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="10.5" stroke="#000" />
<path fill="#FFF" d="M5.993 13.464c.675 0 1.323-.266 1.806-.743l4.11 2.396a2.639 2.639 0 0 0 .368 2.451 2.583 2.583 0 0 0 2.227 1.043 2.59 2.59 0 0 0 2.09-1.3 2.64 2.64 0 0 0 .08-2.477 2.58 2.58 0 0 0-4.292-.54L8.344 11.94c.28-.616.31-1.319.086-1.958l3.952-2.303a2.564 2.564 0 0 0 4.263-.537 2.623 2.623 0 0 0-.078-2.46 2.573 2.573 0 0 0-2.075-1.293 2.566 2.566 0 0 0-2.213 1.033 2.622 2.622 0 0 0-.37 2.433L7.96 9.158a2.573 2.573 0 0 0-4.316.603 2.632 2.632 0 0 0 .172 2.501 2.58 2.58 0 0 0 2.178 1.202Z" />
<path fill="#000" d="M6.936 9.577c.322 0 .631.137.859.383.228.245.355.577.355.924 0 .347-.127.68-.355.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.859.383c-.322 0-.63-.138-.858-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.356-.925c0-.347.129-.679.356-.924.228-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm6.17-3.837c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.924 0 .347-.128.68-.356.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.924.227-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm0 7.883c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.925 0 .346-.128.679-.356.924a1.171 1.171 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.923.227-.245.536-.383.858-.384Zm-6.17-.681c.499 0 .978-.21 1.334-.586l3.036 1.888a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .272 1.93c.385.555 1.003.863 1.645.822.641-.04 1.221-.425 1.544-1.024a2.203 2.203 0 0 0 .059-1.952c-.286-.62-.841-1.044-1.48-1.13-.637-.085-1.272.18-1.69.705l-2.984-1.854c.207-.486.23-1.04.064-1.543l2.92-1.815c.415.522 1.046.784 1.68.7.633-.086 1.184-.507 1.468-1.123a2.188 2.188 0 0 0-.058-1.938c-.32-.595-.895-.977-1.532-1.018-.638-.041-1.251.264-1.635.813a2.179 2.179 0 0 0-.273 1.917L8.389 9.55c-.423-.534-1.07-.798-1.715-.702-.645.096-1.2.54-1.472 1.177a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .126 1.97c.352.59.958.948 1.61.947Z" />
</g>
</svg>
Share
</summary>
<div class="quick-access-bubble">
<ul class="flex gap-6 text-black list-none">
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Andrew Joseph Whiteâs <i>You Werenât Meant to Be Human</i> Pushes a Lot of Buttons&url=https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/” target=”_blank” title=”Twitter”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[15px]"="h-[15px]"" width="18" height="15" viewbox="0 0 18 15" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="twitter" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/" target="_blank" title="Facebook">
<svg class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" fill="currentColor" viewbox="0 0 12 22" width="100%" height="100%" display="block" transitionduration="normal" transitionproperty="none" transitiontimingfunction="ease-out" class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" aria-label="facebook" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M11.558.004L8.677 0C5.44 0 3.349 2.125 3.349 5.416v2.496H.452A.45.45 0 000 8.36v3.618a.45.45 0 00.452.447h2.897v9.127A.45.45 0 003.8 22h3.778c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.448v-9.127h3.387c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.447l.003-3.618a.452.452 0 00-.456-.448h-3.39V5.795c0-1.017.245-1.534 1.582-1.534h1.941c.25 0 .452-.2.452-.447V.457a.45.45 0 00-.452-.448l.01-.005z" fill-rule="nonzero">
</path>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/&media=&description=Andrew Joseph Whiteâs <i>You Werenât Meant to Be Human</i> Pushes a Lot of Buttons” target=”_blank” title=”Pinterest”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[18px]"="h-[18px]"" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="pinterest" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://reactormag.com/feed/" target="_blank" title="RSS Feed">
<svg class="w-[17px] h-[17px]" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="rss feed" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<g clip-path="url(#clip0_1051_121783)">
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</g>
<defs>
<clippath id="clip0_1051_121783">
<rect width="17" height="17" fill="white" transform="translate(0.678711 0.414307)" />
</clippath>
</defs>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
</ul>
</div>
</details>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-media ">
<figure class="w-full h-auto post-hero-image">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="740" height="407" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human-740x407.png" class="w-full object-cover" alt="Cover of You Weren't Meant to Be Human by Andrew Joseph White." srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human-740x407.png 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human-1100x605.png 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human-768x422.png 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human.png 1400w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 740px) 100vw, 740px" /> </figure>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</post-hero>
<div class="wp-block-more-from-category">
<div>
</div>
</div>
<p>I don’t really know what to do with a horror novel like Andrew Joseph White’s <em>You Weren’t Meant to Be Human</em>. I’ve started and stopped this review half a dozen times over the past few days since finishing it. Even now as I type these words, I genuinely don’t know where this review will end up. </p>
<p>First and foremost, you should know that I’m a big ol’ baby when it comes to adult horror. I read a ton of young adult horror—queer YA in particular is one of my favorite horror sub-genres—but little horror written for adults. I prefer my horror in the vein of looming dread rather than creatures bursting out of chests. The book opens with an author’s note that functions as content warnings for pregnancy-related horror as well as suicidal ideation, sexual violence, abuse, self-harm, and combinations thereof. I went into this book knowing that it would push past several of my limits. I still don’t know why I kept reading. Perhaps it was the premise of an autistic trans man falling pregnant in a dystopian near future coming from the mind of one of my favorite queer YA horror novels from last year (<em>Compound Fracture</em>: vicious, brutal, must-read). Perhaps it was because while the content warnings were extensive, they skipped over one specific act (likely to not spoil the novel) that didn’t become apparent until the climax. Or perhaps it was simply because I’d already dropped out of covering two other adult horror novels earlier this year that were too intense for me and I didn’t want to chicken out a third time. </p>
<p>Hm. I’m not doing this right. Let me back up. Crane lives in West Virginia in a not-too-distant future where abortion is mostly illegal and trans healthcare is relegated to black market HRT. After high school, his suicidal ideation hit a boiling point, and that’s when the hive found him. The hive rescued him. The hive made him one of their own. The hive gave him permission to be his true self. Or so it tells him. Or so he tells himself. He transitioned, literally and metaphorically, into his new life. But instead of shedding his old habits and haunted thoughts, they mutated over him into something as terrible on the outside as he felt on the inside. </p>
<p>His lover, Levi, is a vile man who is also infected by the hive. He relishes casual cruelty and lavishes Crane with as much abuse as he desires, and also maybe some he doesn’t want. His and Crane’s relationship is a complicated one, to say the least, one that whole essays could be written on. I am way too much of a sex-indifferent asexual to untangle that sadomasochistic knot, but it was fascinating to read. White takes utterly degrading moments and filters them through Crane’s perspective. We come to understand why he seeks out these encounters, what he gets out of them, and, crucially, what he doesn’t. </p>
<p>His sexual relationship with Levi reflects his bond with the hive. No one knows what the hive—a collection of strange, oversized worms and fly-like creatures—really is, where it came from, or what its ultimate plans are. It needs humans, though, and has pockets of cult-like followers all over the country. It found Crane and brought him into its family, making him do terrible things to others with the promise of being seen for who he is. Until he isn’t. The hive doesn’t truly see him. The hive sees him for how useful he is to it, even when that use forces him to be the person he dreads the most. </p>
<section class="wp-block-shop-the-book shop-the-book">
<h2 class="shop-the-book-headline">Buy the Book</h2>
<div class="shop-the-book-content">
<figure class="shop-the-book-image-desktop image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<div class="flex items-center">
<figure class="shop-the-book-image-mobile image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<h3 class="shop-the-book-title text-h3">You Weren’t Meant to Be Human</h3>
<p class="shop-the-book-author">Andrew Joseph White</p>
</div>
</div>
<button type="button" class="inline-block px-8 py-4 text-center btn tablet:py-3 text-h6 bg-red text-white shop-the-book-button" id="buy_book" data-trigger="modal" data-target="#modal-1758304558" aria-open="false" aria-label="Buy Book">
<span class="inline-flex items-center button-label btn-label">
Buy Book
</span>
</button>
</div>
</div>
<div id="modal-1758304558" class="shop-the-book-modal test">
<div class="shop-the-book-modal-inner">
<button class="js-modal-close absolute top-5 right-5 z-10 test" type="button" aria-label="icon-close">
<svg class="w-[19px] h-[19px]" width="18" height="19" viewbox="0 0 18 19" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="close" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M1 17L17 1" stroke="black" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
<path d="M1 17L17 1" stroke="black" stroke-opacity="0.2" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
<path d="M17 17.0809L1 1.08093" stroke="black" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
<path d="M17 17.0809L1 1.08093" stroke="black" stroke-opacity="0.2" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
</svg>
</button>
<div class="shop-the-book-modal-content">
<figure class="shop-the-book-modal-image-desktop image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<div class="flex items-center">
<figure class="shop-the-book-modal-image-mobile image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<h3 class="shop-the-book-modal-title">You Weren't Meant to Be Human</h3>
<p class="shop-the-book-modal-author">Andrew Joseph White</p>
</div>
</div>
<p class="shop-the-book-modal-label">Buy this book from:</p>
<ul class="not-prose ebook-links ebook-links-shortcode"><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0DV64YWWX?tag=tordotcomgeneral-20" data-book-title="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" data-book-store="Amazon"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">Amazon</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="https://www.anrdoezrs.net/links/7992675/type/dlg/sid/tordotcomgeneral/https://www.barnesandnoble.com/s/9781668038079" data-book-title="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" data-book-store="Barnes and Noble"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">Barnes and Noble</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="http://itunes.apple.com/us/book/isbn9781668038093" data-book-title="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" data-book-store="iBooks"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">iBooks</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="https://www.indiebound.org/book/9781668038079" data-book-title="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" data-book-store="IndieBound"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">IndieBound</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="https://www.target.com/s?searchTerm=9781668038079" data-book-title="You Weren't Meant to Be Human" data-book-store="Target"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">Target</span></a></li></ul>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</section>
<p>The book begins not with Crane’s arrival at the hive but with Jess’. Jess is in many ways what Crane used to be, and in some ways still is. With the help of the hive, she escaped the boyfriend who imprisoned her, but how she’s found herself just as imprisoned by the hive. Everything the hive promised Jess has soured, just as it does for Crane when he ends up pregnant and the hive forces him to carry it to term. The humans in the hive cult use the correct pronouns and don’t call him slurs, but if you’re the one being oppressed they aren’t that much different from run-of-the-mill authoritarian assholes.</p>
<p>Crane is also autistic and selectively mute. White got me thinking a lot about communication, from who chose to communicate with Crane in a way that respected his need to not use his voice to who didn’t. Crane’s verbal silence was, for him, empowering in a way speech never was. It is the one thing he has total control over, a thing that is just for him and no one else, and he chooses to keep it to himself. Before I read this novel, I’d been thinking a lot lately about the memeification of neurodiversity, particularly through video platforms like Reels and TikTok. Videos of people talking about their neurodivergence in cutesy terms or like their issues are little more than a collection of idiosyncrasies. Real day-to-day challenges getting reduced down to something bite-sized that most people can relate to and that everyone else can laugh at. What we don’t often see are folks with greater challenges such as personal hygiene, communication difficulties, complex sensory needs, food limitations, and other things that aren’t quite so quirky. In other words, we talk about autism like it’s a spectrum but we often don’t treat it like one. White never shies away from exploring that spectrum in his books. He doesn’t write from a perspective of “this is bad, I hate being autistic,” but rather from “this is who I am, deal with it or gtfo.”</p>
<p>A story like this could quickly tumble into <em>A Handmaid’s Tale</em> territory, but White has more insightful things to say. This isn’t just a dark dystopian about an autistic trans man going through a dysphoric experience. This is a horror novel. Body horror pops up again and again—heed that <em>Aliens</em>-meets-<em>Midsommar</em> comparison, my friends—as do graphic sexual encounters and psychological terror. The narrative style is unrelenting: violent thoughts, violent acts, violent hopes and dreams. For me, the plot was fairly predictable. Once I got used to the cadence of the horror and figured out Crane’s personality, I could tell where the story was headed. As an avid reader of romance novels, knowing where the story is going isn’t a problem for me. I care more about the journey than the specifics of the destination. </p>
<p>Except this isn’t a romance novel and I couldn’t guess the ending. If I had, I don’t know that I would’ve kept reading. It contains an act that is a hard line for me in fiction. I am a visual reader in that I picture what I see on the page. When I read the word “apple,” I have a very specific image of an apple that pops into my head. When I read, I “see” the scene play out in my mind’s eye. Which is why I have such a hard time with horror. I have to recreate what I read into visuals, and there are some things I don’t want to do that with. There were more than a few parts of this book where I had to skim, and the final confrontation was one of them. White’s choice to write the scene the way he did was probably the correct one for this novel and this main character, but it was too much for me personally. </p>
<p>Now that I’ve talked my way through writing this review (because I also hear what I read on the page in my head as if I were speaking out loud), I think I’ve come around to having a better understanding of why White—and by extension Crane—made certain narrative choices. The book wouldn’t have worked without them, the themes wouldn’t have hit as hard as they did and the power of the story itself would’ve fizzled away like a deflating balloon. This is a book that’s going to push a lot of buttons for a lot of people, in good and bad ways, but I also won’t be surprised when it ends up on a bunch of best-of lists at the end of the year. </p>
<p>So here’s where all this leaves me in terms of my review of <em>You Weren’t Meant to Be Human</em> by Andrew Joseph White. Did I like it? Did I understand it? Do I recommend it? I think my answers are not really, yep, and horror fans should absolutely read it. The content was not what I enjoy reading, and the experience was for me, personally, the literary equivalent of trekking up Mt Everest: arduous while it was happening yet satisfying when done, and with a lot of dead bodies passed along the way. I don’t think I can go through a reading experience like that again, but if I had to go through it at all, I’m glad it was with this book. [end-mark]</p>
<div style="height:5px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<p class="has-sm-font-size"><em><a href="https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/You-Werent-Meant-to-Be-Human/Andrew-Joseph-White/9781668038079" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">You Weren’t Meant to Be Human</a></em> is published by Saga Press.</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/">Andrew Joseph White’s <i>You Weren’t Meant to Be Human</i> Pushes a Lot of Buttons</a> appeared first on <a href="https://reactormag.com">Reactor</a>.</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/">https://reactormag.com/book-review-you-werent-meant-to-be-human-by-andrew-joseph-white/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824072">https://reactormag.com/?p=824072</a></p>
The majority of R.L. Stine’s Fear Street books function as interconnected but standalone narratives: there’s a shared setting and some familiar characters that appear time and again, but generally speaking, you don’t need to have read the previous books in the series in order to jump right in. There are, however, a handful of exceptions, where Stine features a trilogy or series within the larger Fear Street series, like 99 Fear Street trilogy (1994), the Silent Night trilogy (1991-96), and the Cheerleaders series (1992-98). Another of Stine’s lesser known trilogies within the Fear Street series is the Cataluna Chronicles, which includes The Evil Moon, The Dark Secret, and The Deadly Fire (all 1995) and centers around an evil sports car that threatens the life of anyone who dares to drive it. Any book that features a sentient, malevolent car will inevitably invite comparisons with Stephen King’s Christine (1983) and there are some of these in Stine’s books, but the Cataluna Chronicles also has some unique surprises of its own.
The trio of Cataluna Chronicles books are pretty fatalistic and the body count is high. The prologue of the first book, The Evil Moon, follows the misadventures of two young men who steal the Cataluna for a joyride from a used car lot, find themselves powerless in a car that’s charging down the highway at eighty miles an hour, and bail out on the unforgiving pavement, only to be run over by a tractor trailer. From these opening pages, Stine makes it clear that the Cataluna is not messing around and this isn’t going to be one of those Fear Street books where everything turns out mostly okay in the end, explained away by a prank gone awry, mistaken identity, or someone faking their own death. These two boys steal the car and they die. The end. Or at least, the end of the beginning.
After this hard-hitting prologue, The Evil Moon makes an unexpected turn, taking readers not back to the used car lot or familiar Fear Street, but to West Hampshire Colony in 1698. Early colonial America doesn’t really seem like the natural fit for a technohorror(ish) series about an evil car, but it’s where we go and where we first meet fifteen year old Catherine Hatchett, an outcast young woman who is lurking outside the school windows eavesdropping on the lessons within, because as a girl, she has been forbidden attendance. She is curious and smart, able to conjugate the Latin verb tenses that stymie the boys in the classroom, though her reward for her intelligence is to be chased through the woods, assaulted, and ridiculed. Her nickname in the community is “Bad Luck Catherine” and the colonists blame her for everything from their failing crops to their ailing livestock, and even her own mother scolds Catherine, telling her “You have caused enough trouble for one day. You have caused enough trouble for a lifetime!” (17). Catherine was presumably born under a “bad moon,” which marked her body with a crescent moon-shaped birthmark on her temple. Her only friend is Gwendolyn, an old woman and suspected witch who lives in the woods outside of the settlement.
When the West Hampshire Colony votes to expel Catherine from the community and her parents reveal that they’re not actually her parents, with Catherine instead being a foundling child that was left on their doorstep after the death of their own infant, Catherine realizes that there’s more to her story than she has ever known: Gwendolyn is her biological mother, a witch, and a shapeshifter, a gift that has been genetically passed down to Catherine and which she uses to escape the colonists when they attempt to hang her. Catherine turns into a cat to claw out the eyes of Joseph Parker, a boy who seduced and betrayed her, then turns into a rat and forces her furry body down the throat of colony elder Edmund Parker, suffocating him. Gwendolyn is murdered by the angry colonists, leaving Catherine alone with her newfound power, no one to guide her in its use, and no way to escape … until she finds her mother’s final gift, a shiny white sports car that is completely anachronistic and looks very out of place in the dark woods behind Gwendolyn’s cottage. Catherine initially believes it to be a monster: “the creature’s eyes began to glow with a bright yellow light … The monster stretched out as long as her parents’ woodshed. But stood not half as tall. It had four black wheels and clear windowpanes all around. Through those panes she found another wheel of sorts. And two rows of seats, red as blood” (124). It turns out Gwendolyn magically brought this car from the future and it becomes Catherine’s only way to escape the danger in which she finds herself. But she doesn’t make the trip alone: William Parker, brother of Joseph and son of Edmund, is not about to let Catherine get away after murdering his family, and he goes along for this bizarre road trip through time and space.
The Evil Moon, The Dark Secret, and The Deadly Fire trace the Cataluna’s destructive path through Shadyside in 1995, along with Catherine and William’s deadly game of cat and mouse across the centuries. In The Evil Moon, Bryan Folger becomes obsessed with the car when he sees it in a used car lot and is willing to do anything to possess it: he has a part-time job with a florist and steals money from a stranger’s home when he’s there delivering flowers; he breaks into another house to steal more money and when he’s arrested and ends up assigned to community service at the local hospital’s gift shop, he steals money from the register there too. When he sees the Cataluna in his friend Alan’s driveway (because Alan knew how much the car meant to Bryan and bought it for him, which seems excessive, but whatever), Bryan assaults Alan and steals the car. His initial moments of euphoria are overwhelming, but just like the two boys in the prologue, Bryan soon loses control of the Cataluna, which starts driving faster and trying to run down pedestrians and small children, while Bryan screams and attempts to turn the car back toward Alan’s house, figuring if he can get it back where it’s “meant” to be, the nightmare will end. And it kind of does: the car returns to Alan’s house but by the time it gets there, Bryan is dead: “Burst blood vessels had turned his face reddish-blue. A terrifying silent scream twisted his features. His blank eyes bulged. His dead hands still gripped the wheel” (137).
In The Dark Secret, Lauren and Regina Patterson are stepsisters and their parents buy the Cataluna as the girls’ shared car. Regina quickly becomes obsessed with the car, insisting on driving every time the girls go out together, and she nearly runs down a couple of children: one on rollerblades and another on a tricycle. Both kids escape unscathed, though the tricycle is smashed to smithereens as “Regina threw back her head and laughed” (43). The car drives a wedge between Lauren and Regina, and when there’s a series of hit and runs in Shadyside, Lauren is sure it’s Regina. She tries to cover for her stepsister but every time Lauren tries to broach the subject with Regina, she is shut down. When Lauren finally confronts Regina, the truth comes out: Lauren is the hit and run driver, not Regina. While she has repressed the memories of the terrible things that have happened in the car, they all come rushing back to her: “A man’s face pressed against her windshield, face contorted in pain. Blood running from his mouth, smearing across the glass … Metal slamming against metal. A scream of terror. Squealing tires. A body landing on the hood with a heavy thunk “ (129, emphasis original). The car urges Lauren to run down Regina but she resists, plunging the car into a nearby lake and nearly dying in her attempt to get rid of the Cataluna, though Regina swims to her rescue. Even waterlogged, the car’s not finished, though: as the rescue personnel pull the car from the lake, one of the firefighters on scene is captivated, reflecting that “I’d like to get a sports car like that … Man, that car is wicked!” (135, emphasis original). He has no idea. But while Lauren and Regina survive the Cataluna’s curse, plenty of innocent people died along the way, and when Lauren tries to explain that it was the car and not her that is responsible, Regina only says “We’ll talk about it later” (134), which doesn’t offer much in terms of what the criminal consequences of Lauren’s series of vehicular homicides might be.
In the third book of the trilogy, The Deadly Fire, people are at least wise to the Cataluna’s death toll, though a family of race car drivers leverages this reputation into a racetrack gimmick, where fans turn out in droves to see the “Doom Car” in competition. The first race is off to a good start until the Cataluna does what it always does, wresting control from driver Stan McCloy and plowing into the stands, killing both Stan and a number of spectators. While most of the McCloys are understandably ready to be shut of the Cataluna, Stan’s brother Buddy becomes increasingly obsessed with it, sneaking it out of his father’s garage to race it on his own along the dark streets of Shadyside. His fickle on again-off again girlfriend Sara is a race track groupie and only seems interested in Buddy if he’s got the hottest car, his new neighbor Marisol seems intrigued by the Cataluna, and there’s a new guy in town named Will who also fancies himself a race car driver (and quickly becomes a rival for Sara’s affections).
William Parker spends much of the trilogy pursuing Catherine Hatchett from place to place and across centuries, often faced with the riddle of trying to figure out who she has shape-shifted into this time. Immediately after she flees the West Hampshire Colony, he follows her to a nearby farmstead, where he works to determine which of his new friends’ bodies his enemy might be hiding within, attacking the family cat and killing an innocent young woman before he gets it right. This question of Catherine’s shapeshifted form is at the heart of The Deadly Fire as well, where everyone seems to have designs on the Cataluna and no one’s intentions or motivations are particularly clear. When William and Catherine made the temporal leap from 1698 to 1995, Catherine’s spirit was imprisoned in the car while William’s found a home in a new human body. This is a new development: William maintained his own body in the immediate aftermath of Catherine’s violence in the West Hampshire Colony, and before he shows up in a human body as a character in The Deadly Fire, he seems to have been a kind unseen presence watching from the shadows, monitoring the Cataluna’s death toll and serving as an occasional narrator, there, but largely invisible. The prevailing assumption throughout The Deadly Fire is that William is now (uncreatively and lazily) Will, but William’s spirit actually occupies Marisol’s body—and after yet another fatal encounter, where a drag race with the Cataluna ends in Will’s death, Marisol takes the wheel, ready to stop Catherine once and for all.
William’s embodiment in Marisol’s female body is actually handled in a straightforward and nonsensationalized way, and William’s residence in a female form is not sexualized or presented as abject or grotesque. William comfortably occupies this physical form while remaining true to his own identity, telling Catherine matter-of-factly that “I don’t blame you for not recognizing me … But it is me inside this girl’s body. It is me—your old friend William Parker” (117). Once he has revealed his identity, the story seamlessly transitions to referring to him as William and using masculine pronouns, grounded in his identity rather than the physical body he occupies.
William has pursued Catherine across centuries and has dedicated himself tirelessly to learning the secrets of the Cataluna, and as a result, he is able to do what no one else ever has: wrest control of the car from Catherine’s spirit and return it to where he first encountered it, in West Hampshire Colony in 1698. There’s a time travel paradox at work as William tells Catherine “I’m destroying this car nearly three hundred years before your mother was born, Catherine! … Do you know what that means? That means your mother will never exist in this time and place. And so, you will never exist. You will never be born!” (134, emphasis original). While this time travel conundrum offers a retribution of sorts, the Cataluna’s destruction is also grounded in supernatural vengeance, as the spirits of all the people the car has killed emerge to attack and destroy Catherine. And just like that, all of the Cataluna’s horrors are erased and undone, though the danger itself may be reborn as William wakes up disoriented in the woods and returns home to find that his mother has given birth to a baby girl … with a small crescent moon birthmark on her temple. Stine’s Cataluna Chronicles are a curious combination of historical fiction and technohorror, connecting a sentient, malevolent car with historical ostracism that parallels that of the witchcraft hysteria of Salem in 1692. While Catherine is initially presented as sympathetic and even pitiable, she quickly becomes monstrous, consumed with a hate that lasts for hundreds of years. William is presented with similar complexity, driven by vengeance to do some terrible things. In the end, when William succeeds in bringing Catherine back to her own time and destroying the car, the resolution is tenuous and potentially transitory. It could be that with Catherine’s erasure and the car’s destruction, the horrors of both the present and the future have been undone, or with the birth of the new Parker baby with the familiar crescent moon birthmark, the horrors could just be beginning (again).[end-mark]
[Error: Irreparable invalid markup ('<a [...] w-[18px]>') in entry. Owner must fix manually. Raw contents below.]
<p class="syndicationauthor">Posted by Emmet Asher-Perrin</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/">https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824382">https://reactormag.com/?p=824382</a></p><post-hero class="wp-block-post-hero js-post-hero post-hero post-hero-horizontal">
<div class="container container-desktop">
<div class="flex flex-col mx-auto post-hero-container">
<div class="post-hero-content">
<div class="post-hero-tags font-aktiv text-xs tracking-[0.5px] font-medium uppercase">
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/articles/featured-essays/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Featured Essays 0">
Featured Essays
</a>
</span>
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/tag/star-trek/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Star Trek 1">
Star Trek
</a>
</span>
</div>
<h2 class="post-hero-title text-h1"><i>Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’</i> Bumpy Third Season Highlights a Core Problem in Modern TV</h2>
<div class="prose post-hero-description prose--post-hero">Blaming comedy hardly seems fair when there’s a much larger elephant in the room…</div>
<div class="post-hero-wrapper">
<div class="post-hero-inner">
<p class="post-hero-author text-xs font-aktiv uppercase font-medium [&_a]:link-hover">By <a href="https://reactormag.com/author/emmet-asher-perrin/" title="Posts by Emmet Asher-Perrin" class="author url fn" rel="author">Emmet Asher-Perrin</a></p>
<span class="post-hero-symbol relative top-[-2px] hidden tablet:block">|</span>
<p class="text-xs uppercase post-hero-publish font-aktiv">
Published on September 18, 2025
</p>
</div>
</div>
<div class="quick-access post-hero-quick-access mt-[17px] tablet:hidden">
<div class="flex gap-[30px] tablet:gap-6">
<a href="https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/#comments" class="flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase translate-x-[1px] translate-y-[1px]">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 18 18" aria-label="comment" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-comment-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-comment-quick-access-">Comment</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<path fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" d="M6.3 18a.9.9 0 0 1-.9-.9v-2.7H1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 0 12.6V1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 1.8 0h14.4A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 18 1.8v10.8a1.8 1.8 0 0 1-1.8 1.8h-5.49l-3.33 3.339a.917.917 0 0 1-.63.261H6.3Z" />
<path stroke="#000" d="M5.9 14.4v-.5H1.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3-1.3V1.8A1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.8.5h14.4a1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.3 1.3v10.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3 1.3h-5.698l-.146.147-3.324 3.333a.417.417 0 0 1-.282.12H6.3a.4.4 0 0 1-.4-.4v-2.7Z" />
</g>
</svg>
22
</a>
<details class="relative quick-access-details">
<summary class="quick-access-share flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 22 22" aria-label="share" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-share-new-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-share-new-quick-access-">Share New</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="11" fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" />
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="10.5" stroke="#000" />
<path fill="#FFF" d="M5.993 13.464c.675 0 1.323-.266 1.806-.743l4.11 2.396a2.639 2.639 0 0 0 .368 2.451 2.583 2.583 0 0 0 2.227 1.043 2.59 2.59 0 0 0 2.09-1.3 2.64 2.64 0 0 0 .08-2.477 2.58 2.58 0 0 0-4.292-.54L8.344 11.94c.28-.616.31-1.319.086-1.958l3.952-2.303a2.564 2.564 0 0 0 4.263-.537 2.623 2.623 0 0 0-.078-2.46 2.573 2.573 0 0 0-2.075-1.293 2.566 2.566 0 0 0-2.213 1.033 2.622 2.622 0 0 0-.37 2.433L7.96 9.158a2.573 2.573 0 0 0-4.316.603 2.632 2.632 0 0 0 .172 2.501 2.58 2.58 0 0 0 2.178 1.202Z" />
<path fill="#000" d="M6.936 9.577c.322 0 .631.137.859.383.228.245.355.577.355.924 0 .347-.127.68-.355.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.859.383c-.322 0-.63-.138-.858-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.356-.925c0-.347.129-.679.356-.924.228-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm6.17-3.837c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.924 0 .347-.128.68-.356.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.924.227-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm0 7.883c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.925 0 .346-.128.679-.356.924a1.171 1.171 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.923.227-.245.536-.383.858-.384Zm-6.17-.681c.499 0 .978-.21 1.334-.586l3.036 1.888a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .272 1.93c.385.555 1.003.863 1.645.822.641-.04 1.221-.425 1.544-1.024a2.203 2.203 0 0 0 .059-1.952c-.286-.62-.841-1.044-1.48-1.13-.637-.085-1.272.18-1.69.705l-2.984-1.854c.207-.486.23-1.04.064-1.543l2.92-1.815c.415.522 1.046.784 1.68.7.633-.086 1.184-.507 1.468-1.123a2.188 2.188 0 0 0-.058-1.938c-.32-.595-.895-.977-1.532-1.018-.638-.041-1.251.264-1.635.813a2.179 2.179 0 0 0-.273 1.917L8.389 9.55c-.423-.534-1.07-.798-1.715-.702-.645.096-1.2.54-1.472 1.177a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .126 1.97c.352.59.958.948 1.61.947Z" />
</g>
</svg>
Share
</summary>
<div class="quick-access-bubble">
<ul class="flex gap-6 text-black list-none">
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=<i>Star Trek: Strange New Worldsâ</i> Bumpy Third Season Highlights a Core Problem in Modern TV&url=https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/” target=”_blank” title=”Twitter”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[15px]"="h-[15px]"" width="18" height="15" viewbox="0 0 18 15" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="twitter" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/" target="_blank" title="Facebook">
<svg class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" fill="currentColor" viewbox="0 0 12 22" width="100%" height="100%" display="block" transitionduration="normal" transitionproperty="none" transitiontimingfunction="ease-out" class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" aria-label="facebook" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M11.558.004L8.677 0C5.44 0 3.349 2.125 3.349 5.416v2.496H.452A.45.45 0 000 8.36v3.618a.45.45 0 00.452.447h2.897v9.127A.45.45 0 003.8 22h3.778c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.448v-9.127h3.387c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.447l.003-3.618a.452.452 0 00-.456-.448h-3.39V5.795c0-1.017.245-1.534 1.582-1.534h1.941c.25 0 .452-.2.452-.447V.457a.45.45 0 00-.452-.448l.01-.005z" fill-rule="nonzero">
</path>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/&media=&description=<i>Star Trek: Strange New Worldsâ</i> Bumpy Third Season Highlights a Core Problem in Modern TV” target=”_blank” title=”Pinterest”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[18px]"="h-[18px]"" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="pinterest" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://reactormag.com/feed/" target="_blank" title="RSS Feed">
<svg class="w-[17px] h-[17px]" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="rss feed" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<g clip-path="url(#clip0_1051_121783)">
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</g>
<defs>
<clippath id="clip0_1051_121783">
<rect width="17" height="17" fill="white" transform="translate(0.678711 0.414307)" />
</clippath>
</defs>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
</ul>
</div>
</details>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-media ">
<figure class="w-full h-auto post-hero-image">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="740" height="493" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-307-what-is-starfleet-02-740x493.jpg" class="w-full object-cover" alt="Rebecca Romijn, Anson Mount, and Christina Chong in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 3 episode "What Is Starfleet?"" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-307-what-is-starfleet-02-740x493.jpg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-307-what-is-starfleet-02-1100x733.jpg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-307-what-is-starfleet-02-768x512.jpg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-307-what-is-starfleet-02.jpg 1200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 740px) 100vw, 740px" /> </figure>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</post-hero>
<div class="wp-block-more-from-category">
<div>
</div>
</div>
<p>The general feeling toward <em>Strange New Worlds</em>’ third season has certainly been more tepid than the previous two. And while everyone rushes to give their opinion as to why, there’s a common theme developing that concerns me. Namely, a lot of blame is being placed on the more comedic episodes of this season, to the extent that it’s possible the series showrunners felt need to provide some reassurance. An <a href="https://www.cinemablend.com/streaming-news/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-showrunners-compare-season-4-to-season-3-difference-behind-the-scenes" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">interview over at Cinemablend</a> has co-showrunner Henry Alonso Myers promising the season four will be the show’s “best work,” but also that—</p>
<figure class="wp-block-pullquote has-text-align-left"><blockquote><p>“I think that we’re probably a little more serious in four[…]”</p></blockquote></figure>
<p>Mr. Myers, say it ain’t so.</p>
<p>In fairness, the majority of the interview reasserts that “genre-hopping” will still occur, and that the showrunners themselves thought any unevenness in the current season could be attributed to the various Hollywood strikes occurring while they were attempting to get season three made. But that interests me far less than how quick viewers were to jump on <em>comedy</em> being the culprit in <em>Strange New Worlds</em>’ series woes.</p>
<p>We’ve come back to this old fight, I see.</p>
<p>It’s no secret that plenty of fans don’t like it when Star Trek gets “goofy.” In many minds, a science fiction series that takes itself seriously has no business engaging in shenanigans (or hijinks, as T’Pring would have it) of any kind. When Trek goes off the rails or jumps that shark, their socialist utopian future is giving up a little of its hard-won pedigree, as it were.</p>
<p>I’m no big fan of pedigree in general, but I would like to point out that this take is flagrantly subjective and equally “goofy.” Many of Trek’s most famous and beloved episodes are among its silliest, and it’s not reasonable to expect a series that used to run 22-plus episode seasons to have morality plays and deep thoughts aplenty every single episode. Pretending that comedy brings Star Trek down is akin to claiming that a key spice is ruining the flavor of a dish; you may not like the amount of said spice, the flavor balance overall, but you cannot make the soup without it.</p>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-full"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="740" height="555" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/trek-tribbles.jpg" alt="Scotty holding a pile of tribble in front of a dismayed Kirk and Spock in "The Trouble With Tribbles"" class="wp-image-251918" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/trek-tribbles.jpg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/trek-tribbles-140x105.jpg 140w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 740px) 100vw, 740px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Image: Paramount</figcaption></figure>
<p>Volume would seem to be part of the complaint on many-a-viewer’s lips—the Cinemablend piece linked above specifically notes that season three contains <em>three</em> lighter-leaning episodes, making up nearly a third of the season’s ten-episode run. Too many, it would seem. But I’ll cry foul on this one: To start, that was the same number as last season (“Charades,” “Those Old Scientists,” and “Subspace Rhapsody”). So if you enjoyed season two, you’re misplacing your ire.</p>
<p>But when we get into successful Star Trek seasons in general, “more than a quarter, less than a third” is a good rule on lighter episodes. For example, take the <em>Original Series</em> itself, and its highly successful second season. Of a 26-episode run, I count at least seven comedic/lighter stories (sorry, “Catspaw” counts, it’s a flipping <em>Halloween</em> episode). That’s 26.9%, or 27% rounded up. Only a few points shy of <em>Strange New Worlds</em>’ 30%, notably. And, perhaps even more relevant, the third season of the <em>Original Series</em> is counted as dismal fare overall by even the most devoted Trek fans. You know how many comedic episodes that season had? <em>Zero.</em></p>
<p>Unless we’re counting “Spock’s Brain” as intentionally comedic. Which… we can if we must, I suppose.</p>
<p>The truth of the trouble is, there are several points working against <em>Strange New Worlds</em> in its basic construction, and these problems were always bound to creep up as time wore on. The first and most egregious culprit: It simply doesn’t have enough episodes.</p>
<p><em>Star Trek: Discovery</em>, the initial salvo in Trek’s resurgence on television, started out with 15-episode seasons. This is a great sweet spot, one that sits between what we had in classic series, and what we’re currently getting. <em>Lower Decks</em> capped out at 13 episodes per season, which isn’t ideal, but still better than <em>Strange New Worlds</em>, and the more typical episode run in our age of streaming TV. <em>Prodigy</em> gave us whopping 20-episode seasons, and managed to do more in its limited run that most of the shows getting a “full” five seasons. (Bring us back to seven seasons, I beg you.)</p>
<p><em>Star Trek: Picard</em> only had 10-episode seasons, and you could argue that it worked to the show’s detriment, particularly where its new characters were concerned. But even that’s not a fair comparison to what’s happening with <em>Strange New Worlds</em>—why? Because that series was focused on one of the most beloved characters in Star Trek’s history, a man with more narrative attached to his name than nearly any other, the eponymous Jean-Luc Picard. The show also worked under the auspices of arc-based television, meaning that those 10 episodes were intended to tell a complete story; not so with SNW’s episodic plots.</p>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1100" height="565" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/trek-picard-309-1-1100x565.jpg" alt="Picard in the captain's chair onf Star Trek: Picard" class="wp-image-739075" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/trek-picard-309-1-1100x565.jpg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/trek-picard-309-1-740x380.jpg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/trek-picard-309-1-768x394.jpg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/trek-picard-309-1.jpg 1200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Image: CBS / Paramount+</figcaption></figure>
<p>By the time <em>Strange New Worlds</em> ends—don’t forget, the final season is set give audiences just <em>six</em> episodes—it will only truly have <em>two</em> seasons worth of episodes when comparing it to Trek as we knew it. An entire series comprised of 46 stories. There are only three shorter Trek series: <em>Prodigy</em>, unceremoniously cancelled before it could prove its mettle; the <em>Animated Series</em>, made to bank on audience fervor in the wake of TOS’ cancellation, and thought of by many as an extension of the <em>Original Series</em> itself; and <em>Picard</em>, which was never intended to be a full series, and only went on as long as its leading man was interested in going along for the ride. Is it any wonder that we’re feeling cheated already?</p>
<p>Season three of <em>Strange New Worlds</em> isn’t working for many fans because we’re being given mid-series story arcs without the amount of narrative needed to back those arcs up. Spock’s we’re-not-labelling-it romance with La’an? It’s adorable, but it does seem to spring out of nowhere, founded entirely on the actors’ incredible work in their dance sequences. Actors Ethan Peck and Christina Chong are forced to sell the relationship on chemistry alone with absolutely no buildup—audiences can fill in the gaps, but the gaps we got used to be far smaller than these. As a result, it makes Spock appear either confused or kinda fickle, and vaults right over the steps La’an needed to take in order to be ready for a relationship. (The woman who sang “How Would That Feel” literally five episodes previous is not there yet! It’s only been a few months since then!)</p>
<p>How about Pike and Batel’s partnership speedrun and tearful goodbye? Marie was never much of a fan favorite as a character (and some of the reasons here are complicated, but plenty of them are rooted in weird sexist ideas about who is the right match for Captain Papa Hair Wax), but the choice to have her essentially give up her life to be a time guardian against Ultimate Evil is… it’s just bad, y’all. Particularly when she argues that she never fit anywhere since she was saved from being a Gorn incubator, when she literally nabbed her dream job two episodes previous. And the lifetime-in-a-bottle sequence that we’re supposed to mourn over? Sorry, <em>Farscape</em> and <em>The Magicians</em> did it better—and plenty of other series besides, including TNG’s eternally famous “The Inner Light.”</p>
<p>You know what might have helped? Seeing this relationship bloom over three full seasons of television. It’s difficult to focus on the tragedy of Pike and Batel not getting their rote, highly abridged, extremely heteronormative lifetime—their daughter is gonna marry Admiral April’s son? <em>really??</em> you had no other ideas?—when we’ve barely seen them together as a couple, and any depth to their partnership only got focus in this season.</p>
<figure class="wp-block-image aligncenter size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1100" height="733" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-306-sehlat-ate-its-tail-01-1100x733.jpg" alt="Paul Wesley as Kirk in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season three episode "The Sehlat That Ate Its Hat"" class="wp-image-821232" srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-306-sehlat-ate-its-tail-01-1100x733.jpg 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-306-sehlat-ate-its-tail-01-740x493.jpg 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-306-sehlat-ate-its-tail-01-768x512.jpg 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-306-sehlat-ate-its-tail-01-1536x1024.jpg 1536w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/star-trek-snw-306-sehlat-ate-its-tail-01-2048x1366.jpg 2048w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1100px) 100vw, 1100px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Photo Credit: Marni Grossman / Paramount+</figcaption></figure>
<p>How about Erica Ortega’s difficulty adjusting back into her job after almost being murdered by a Gorn at the start of the season? Hate to say this, but it’s hard to care much about that arc when we don’t really have a full picture of Erica as a person. Melissa Navia is one of the most charming actors on the show, hands down, but what do we actually <em>know</em> about Erica? That she’s great at her job, likes pranks, and loves to razz people. That’s about it. (Oh, and that she’s a bit, uh, xenophobic when compared to her companions, which is awkward as hell, particularly when the show doesn’t address it much.) There’s plenty we can guess at, but again, when it comes to on-screen development, we’ve been given practically nothing. When we finally get something real juicy—like La’an killing Erica’s new Gorn friend, assuming her to be a threat to Erica’s life in a moment of split-second trauma-backed terror—the complexity of that pain is mentioned, but not truly explored.</p>
<p>Which brings us to another problem that <em>Strange New Worlds</em> is uniquely poised to drown under: It wants to be a show that plucks at that nostalgia harp every chance it gets, while also offering something sexy, bright, and new. The result is a lot of confusion around who should be getting focus in the series: while the show has a better female main character cast balance than nearly all Trek shows on record, it’s clear that there’s some fear around spending too much time with those characters in favor of Pike and Spock (and now Scotty and Kirk).</p>
<p>For the record, I’m not one of the fans who gets annoyed every time dear ol’ Jim shows up—I think he should, much in the same way Doctor McCoy is constantly on the bridge of the <em>Enterprise</em> when he has <em>absolutely no reason</em> to be. I want to watch Kirk and Spock <s>flirt</s> bond at every available opportunity, and have enjoyed most of the choices SNW makes in filling in the edges of well-known and beloved characters. But this confusion means that I’m not getting enough of either the newer characters <em>or</em> the legacy ones. It results in a lot of uncomfortable storytelling choices; ones where characters make decisions too quickly to understand their motivations or changes of heart; ones where female characters get plenty of screentime, but none of the depth that their male counterparts receive; ones where <a href="https://reactormag.com/bioessentialism-in-star-trek-strange-new-worlds/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">bioessentialism paints entire species with crude brushes</a> without a second thought.</p>
<p>And again, the answer is simple: Give us <em>more</em>.</p>
<p>I know more about Deanna Troi than I may ever know about Una Chin-Riley because despite being far less central to <em>Next Generation</em>’s overall narrative, I’ve spent days, weeks even, with the counselor. That’s how much narrative space she takes up. Television has forgotten that much of our love of the medium was born of <em>time</em>, plain and endless. The glimmer of prestige led streamers to copy television formats with powerful arcs and singular narratives when most of the allure TV used to provide was company.</p>
<p>What <em>Strange New Worlds</em> has accidentally proven is that you can’t have “episodic” TV without a whole lot of episodes. It would be nice if someone holding the cash at Paramount realized it, and finally gave us back what we’ve all been missing.[end-mark]</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/"><i>Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’</i> Bumpy Third Season Highlights a Core Problem in Modern TV</a> appeared first on <a href="https://reactormag.com">Reactor</a>.</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/">https://reactormag.com/star-trek-strange-new-worlds-bumpy-third-season-highlights-a-core-problem-in-modern-tv/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824382">https://reactormag.com/?p=824382</a></p>
Welcome or welcome back, folks! In the Anime Grab Bag series, we dive into the depths of specific anime subgenres and hunt, perhaps futilely, for hidden gems. Each month, long-time otaku and old friends Leah and Bridget spin a custom roulette wheel composed of qualifying anime and watch three random pilot episodes. You can find this volume’s wheel here!
While the wheel may contain almost every possible title in the subgenre, your hosts must abide by the following rules:
Each show must be an anime that at least one host has never seen.
Each show must be available to stream somewhere so readers can join in if they want to.
We are forbidden from doing any research on the show before viewing it, although a simple Google search and some Wikipedia-ing during and after are fair game.
We react to our selections and share our thoughts on where they fit into the anime landscape, commenting on everything from plot to character design, making comparisons to other series, and finally asking the most important question: Would we watch more of this?
Feel free to play along by watching these shows (if you dare), spinning the wheel to meet your fate, or sharing your thoughts below.
This week, we delve into a subgenre we have an unexpected soft spot for: niche sports. While there are plenty of anime about major sports like baseball, soccer, and volleyball, we thought we’d lean into some of the more unlikely sports, or those with a peculiar twist. Also? We invited Bridget’s friend Daniel to join us.
L: Bridget, do you consider yourself an athlete?
B: (extensive giggling)…No.
L: What’s the most athletic thing you do?
B: On a day-to-day, I take a short ten-minute walk from my car to my workplace. And then at work, sometimes I do shipping.
L: And I say I hike, but mostly I just find a forest and wander through it until I find a shrine or temple. I am not a Patagonia girl. I’m a Michigander, and I love swimming, but like a frog, mostly. Team sports? Absolutely not.
B: Now and then, I go watch a baseball game. I do occasionally like a lady wrestler, e.g. Rhea Ripley.
L: So let the record state: we play a lot more tabletop than sports.
B: Hey, I told Daniel it was sports week. But I didn’t tell him it was niche sports week.
L: (laughs)I welcome this deception.
B: Also, did you know there’s a pole-dancing anime called Pole Princess!!?
L: Now that is an athletic sport, and it takes way more coordination than I have ever had.
B: And you gotta have that core strength. Hey, does Eyeshield 21 count as a niche sport because it’s the only anime about American football?
L: I mean, every sport’s niche to you and me.
(ENTER Daniel, aforementioned gamer friend of Bridget’s, whose cowardice and/or wisdom made him decline an invitation to our isekai wheel)
D: Hey guys.
B: Daniel. What would you say is your daily level of sports interaction?
D: I sometimes play basketball with a six-year-old.
B: See, we’re bringing in an expert on this one.
D: I got some weights right here. I could be doing reps while we watch sports anime. Does Rocket League count as a sport?
L: What about Katamari?
B: I would dominate. I would be a gold medalist.
D: Come on, guys, esports are not real sports. Is there an esports anime?
L: I think you just spoke it into existence.
First Spin: Yawara! A Fashionable Judo Girl (Madhouse, 1989)
Credit: Madhouse
B: I want it to stop on Umamusumeso bad. But it stopped on one with a really long name that I have never heard of. It’s about a girl doing judo at the Olympic Games in Atlanta?
L: Wait, that art style. I’m sorry, but isn’t that… is this by Urasawa? No way. The guy who wrote Monster and Pluto also wrote this? How don’t we know this already? Psychological horror with child murderers, but first?
L: Being a salaryman is a lot of work, but is it a sport?
B: This actually looks quite fun. Look at them drinking soju after their badminton tournament.
D: What’s a soju?
B: It’s an alcoholic drink made from rice where when you drink a quarter of it you think, “This is nice juice,” but if you drink more of it you think, “I am going to die.”
L: The character designer is the person who illustrated Durarara!!. Does this mean they are going to be edgy city boys who hold knives? The poster looks completely unrelated to badminton until you notice the giant birdie in the foreground.
D: Wait, isn’t that called a shuttlecock? Am I making that up?
L: In my neck of the woods we called it a birdie. It’s a regional thing!
Viewing Summary
Most sports anime follow predictable, if comforting, story beats. The hero is usually one of two types: the overly enthusiastic underdog who, like most shonen leads, proves the naysayers wrong through pure force of will and practice, practice, practice! The second type is the foil to this hero, the taciturn, gloomy-gus wunderkind with trauma to work through. Some of the best sports anime out there use this dynamic to build character arcs with momentum—a genuine push and pull between opposing personalities. Be they friends, rivals, lovers, or some combination, solid sports anime know that you need the sun to illuminate the moon, and the moon to appreciate the sun.
In Haikyuu!, Hinata is a ray of light, and Kageyama is the looming mountain. When well done, dynamics like these are a large part of what makes sports anime appealing even to those of us who have zero interest in actual sports. Watching people who are very different learning to work together and accomplish things scratches a very human itch. Salaryman’s Club appears to get that, but also throws in the unease of being a new adult entering the workforce.
B: I like that they aren’t kids. That’s always refreshing, and you don’t see that a lot in sports anime.
L: I wonder how much of it will be a send-up of workplace culture. Like, the episode titles are things like “Synergy,” “Assign,” “Feedback,” “Presentation,” and, um, “Breast”?
D: Is “Breast” really a central part of the workplace?
L: I’m sure it’ll be an insightful take on workplace harassment.
A former badminton prodigy, our hero Mikoto is fired in one of the first scenes, and then his mom tells him he can’t move back home because she has given his room to her pet iguana. To be fair, it’s a really cute iguana wearing a ribbon.
Credit: Liden Films
Now, Mikoto could have gone pro, but something he experienced in high school—something that deterred him from ever playing doubles again—has haunted him, and now he sometimes freezes on the court. The flashback is hazy, but…
D: Gasp! He killed a man during badminton?
L: Or ruined a friendship, at least.
In the present day, our tortured protagonist moves to Saitama, where he has been hired to play for Sunlight Beverage’s corporate team. During his commute on his first day, he comes across a handsome, sleepy drunk sprawled out on a children’s playground. The man awakes cheery-faced and helps Mikoto “fix” his tie. We already know this guy’ll be his boss or something like it in another minute, but we embrace it because, heck, the scene is pretty charming. Anyhow, Mikoto learns after arriving in the office that yes, the park weirdo, Tatsuru Miyazumi, is both coworker and teammate. We also learn that Mikoto really thought his whole job was badminton, but turns out he has to work in the office all day first.
D: Is this a thing? Do companies actually hire people just so they can participate in after-work badminton tournaments?
L: Look, I don’t know. But in Japan, there are all kinds of wild reasons that people get hired, and a lot of the culture is about unspoken rules and asserting dominance indirectly. So, like, maybe there’s a corporate culture where companies that win “friendly” sports meetups gain the upper hand or respect on a bureaucratic level?
B: Did I tell you the workplace right next to my office is like a studio for Bravo? And those people don’t work; they’re always outside playing badminton and pickleball. But they also make Bravo reality TV shows?
Animation-wise, Ryman’s Club is sumptuous. The character designs are sharp and appealing. Everything from bottle labels to bullet train seats to the “Familiar Mart” signage is lovingly rendered. This pilot looks great, and the soundtrack is cool and a little jazzy, and clearly the director, Aimi Yamauchi, watched a lot of Haikyuu!! and took notes on how to pace tense, exciting sports matches involving nets.
Anyhow, after the workday, when these salarymen head to a local middle school to practice and a kid accuses them, not unfairly, of being weirdoes for doing so, we hear Mikoto declare that he will never play doubles. Of course, Tatsuru challenges him to a match. If Mikoto wins, no doubles, but if Tatsuru does? Well. And we all know what will happen, because we need to see these two play doubles and learn to respect each other. It is also important to note that sports anime are infamous for queerbaiting—or maybe it would be more accurate to say wooing Shounen-Ai enthusiasts. These two are striking those notes, too, with ease.
D: He’s the bad boy of badminton.
B: He’s going to have a character arc!
Also, another reason this anime was on the niche wheel, aside from being, erm, corporate badminton? Mikoto might be a little psychic, although it turns out that his power of “foresight” is less than literal, and instead a classic example of the sports anime trope of giving athletic talents powerful nicknames, like when Kuroko’s eyes flash blue when he enters his Zone. In Mikoto’s case, his teammates refer to him as an “esper type” and imply his ability to estimate what a player will do next borders on psychic.
As a final treat, Daniel and Bridget are delighted to realize that Sunlight Beverage’s rowdy, Yankee-looking coach is voiced by Takaya Kuroda, who plays their beloved Kiryu in Like a Dragon.
Predictable but skillfully handled, the episode finishes strong by revealing the fact that our lead men will be—gasp!—roommates!
Credit: Liden Films
Conclusions
B: I enjoyed that.
L: That was a solid pilot.
B: I hope it’s like Magilumiere, where it incorporates a level of office life into the story.
… And then an after-credits scene takes us by surprise when it implies that Mikoto and Tatsuru met years earlier, when Mikoto was a child on that same playground, and Tatsuru either a teen or college student, and suddenly there may be cause for unease on the BL-pandering front.
B: Oh damn! He’s been on this shit for so long…
L: Now it’s creepy! Thanks for that, show!
B: Maybe it only seems sinister because, as aging BL fans, we are used to keeping our guard up. We’ll see. Because I really like it when anime features adults in an adult setting. For example, I really liked Nisekoibecause it was about geeks falling in love in an office.
L: This may also be a show about how becoming an adult is partly about forgiving the disasters of your youth.
Would we watch more?
B: I would watch more of that just to listen to more of Kiryu.
D: Same.
L: If I were still a regular weekly anime viewer, I would put that in my rotation. The foundations here were decent.
Third Spin: Pretty Rhythm: Aurora Dream (Tatsunoko Production, 2011)
B: They are ice skating idols. But they can do their ice-skating idol stuff because of prism technology. It’s kind of like Jewelpet, except Pretty Rhythm usually has no animals, except this version (Aurora Dream) does. The other ones don’t have animals; they just have dead dads and school drama.
D: This is… a sports anime? I am looking at this poster and I see not one ice skate. I just see dancing and microphones. And sheet music!
L: No, they do have skates. Look at their boots. Welp. Bridget. Have you seen this?
B: …yes.
L: Daniel, have you seen this?
D: Um, yeah. Totally.
L: Oh no! I have seen it too, so it’s totally disqualified, damn.
B: No, you have not! But it’s okay because it is literally not streaming anywhere, so it would be disqualified anyway. But while I have this opportunity, I just want to say Pretty Rhythm: Rainbow Liveis the better series.
L: At least we got to hear the joy in your voice.
B: Sometimes life is hard.
Fourth Spin: Tamayomi (Studio A-Cat, 2020)
Credit: Studio A-Cat
B: Ooh, the next one is Tamayomi? It’s lesbian baseball!
B: What’s with the rim lighting on their thighs? Is that supposed to be muscle?
L: Well, yeah, they’re really strong. Also, is the only thing that makes this niche that they’re girls, Bridget?
B: Look, I wanted sapphic baseball on the wheel, okay.
D: I googled “Tamayomi,” and one of the first things that came up was “Tamayomi abs?” So I clicked on it and yes, they have abs.
L: Maybe my gut is wrong. Maybe this is going to be an amazing representation…
Viewing Summary
First things first: the drop in production value between Ryman’s Club and this show is comparable to base-jumping into the Grand Canyon. Within seconds, Daniel says, “Wow, definitely a step back in the animation department,” and truly, folks, it’s rough. While Tamayomi is two years older than Salaryman’s Club, no anime from 2020 should look this bad. And it’s not just about a wobbly, inconsistent animation: The anatomy is tragic. Sometimes their butts are incredibly square, and the size of their cleavage varies depending on the scene, and so does the placement of their eyes on their faces, and no one in the art department knew how to draw someone from a back view.
L: Where is the budget? Not in their butts.
D: Butt-gdet.
B: Oh no, these pants are bad. What year was this? This was inexcusable!
B and D: 2020!!!
Here’s the thing: as otaku, we have sometimes loved shows with subpar animation. Sometimes, especially in decades past, studios made the most of a limited budget and the brutal weekly time constraints of churning out fresh episodes. Fans suffered through a few ugly episodes of even otherwise wonderful shows. We must remember that even Yuri!!! On Ice has a few potato episodes. And while Studio Deen has made a few great shows, it retains a reputation for starting strong but failing to budget, so their animation tends to get worse and worse as a series progresses.
As otaku, we learn to tolerate a certain degree of shoddy work if the story redeems it. But in cases like Tamayomi’s, no amount of sapphic energy can distract us from how bad this looks, especially since the story is as dry as sandpaper.
D: Everyone is dopey-looking.
B: I kind of like it.
L: Denial.
Anyhow, the plot? A girls’ high school with a baseball club that’s been put on hiatus has somehow attracted tons of talented aspiring baseball players, including our lead character, a milquetoast, forgettable girl named Yomi. No doubt they will all work hard to reestablish the club, assuming the animators can figure out how to draw them doing so. What are the odds that every girl our heroine meets will also be obsessed with baseball?
Credit: Studio A-Cat
L: Gee, there are so many good baseball players at this school where there’s no baseball team! It must be fate, or bad writing! One of the two!
Soon, Yomi meets a pair of twins who also love baseball.
L: We didn’t know they were twins because everyone looks the same already.
D: Or we didn’t know they were twins because their hair was different. Is this a universe without men? Have we achieved that?
B: This too is yuri. I am not immune.
Like our previous sports anime lead, Yomi has trauma to work through. Except, well, it’s really not entirely clear what that trauma is? Apparently, she was a really, really strong pitcher, and no one could handle her pitches. Or maybe it was her terrible aim, because midway through this episode, she throws a ball with all her might directly into another girl’s helmet.
B: Holy shit, she could have died!
L: If there wasn’t a helmet, she’d be gone. What was that one movie from the ’90s where a kid accidentally kills his friend’s mom by throwing a baseball that hits her in the skull?
D:What?
B: Was it a Final Destination movie?
L: No, more along the lines of What’s Eating Gilbert Grape or My Girl or something, one of those extra-bleak coming-of-age movies from that era… oh, Google says it’s Simon Birch. 1998.
D: This is how you know an anime is good. When you’re pulling up traumatic movies from your childhood instead of watching it.
Anyhow, we are treated to a messy series of flashbacks of Yomi being rejected by other girls for being a weird baseball freak. And no one would practice with her. We watch the same animation of her pitching at least three more times.
B: This show looks so much older than it is. It looks like a show from 2006, and not a good one.
L: Look, the old anime had excuses, but I don’t need new anime looking like shit!
D: We can’t go back.
So yes, we more or less check out halfway through. They stand. She pitches. We question the art department.
D: Will we get a sixth shot of her throwing the ball?
L: This is so boring.
B: I am weak to anything yuri, but even I can admit that it’s boring.
L: That’s its gravest sin.
D: Is her trauma that she was too good at baseball for the other girls?
B: She’s got the God-Hand.
L: She’s got a booty, but only at one angle. A booty that do quit.
D: Same.
Conclusions
L: If the pilot looks this bad, how much worse will it look in a few episodes’ time?
D: I didn’t like this one. You’ll notice in the other anime they actually played a badminton match, but in this one, she just threw a ball a few times. Not a single ball was hit in this episode.
B: I think the trauma was that no one was able to cook on her level. Or something. Sometimes Daniel and I say, after gaming, “That was a game on paper. It was, and we played.” In this case, we cannot say this was not an anime sports, and we watched it.
D: Sports? I dunno.
B: It made me wish I was watching something like Stella Jogakuin, or any all-girls sports anime done right. Birdie Wing. Anything. Have either of you watched baseball anime before?
L: I loved Big Windup! And the appeal of that one was, again, the dynamics between the catcher and pitcher. The pitcher is the most nervous kid alive, with crippling anxiety, but the catcher is gentle and patient and encourages him rather than giving up on him. It was also BL fodder, for better or for worse, and I loved it a lot. It was more about learning to cope with a panic disorder. The sports anime I like are about relationships and embracing perceived flaws as strengths.
B: Sports anime are best when they’re about people learning to see their differences as advantages, and how loving something doesn’t mean everyone has to do it the same way. I think baseball makes for good sports anime because there’s a lot of introspection involved during the game, and a lot of time to consider decisions.
L: It can’t be the horse-girls. Do we believe her, Daniel?
D: Cut to the wheel, and it’s just all Umamusume.
B: I’ll take a screenshot to prove it.
L: How many times has she spun the wheel in a different tab? Let’s inspect this image.
D: We’re checking the pixels.
L: Bridget, you’re obsessed with the phone game, right?
B: It has reached the point that now, when I open social media, the algorithm gives me actual horse facts about real horses. May I give you a horse fact before we begin?
L: Can we stop you?
D: Please do.
B: One of the horses in Umamusume, Kitasan Black, after retiring—all of the horses in the franchise are retired or have passed—he just loved running so much that he would challenge all other horses to a race, so they started putting overweight horses next to Kitasan Black because he would amp them up and help them get healthy.
L: I just want you all to know that Kitasan Black is a brown horse.
Viewing Summary
D: Well, this is already funny.
We are told in the opening scene of Umamusume that the series is set in a parallel universe where the spirits of horses from our world are embodied by horse-girls who are, well, born to run.
D: Do they have hooves? No, they don’t. Do they have two sets of ears, or will their hair cover the human pair so we never know?
B: It’s a Schrödinger’s Ear situation.
L: Okay, but what if you were born a horse-girl and you hated running? What would happen to you? That’s the story I want to hear.
D: You get turned into glue.
B: Honestly, that is a joke in the series.
Credit: P.A. Works
Though I tease Bridget, Umamusume: Pretty Derby, an anime based on a racehorse-girl phone game, has seen a huge surge in global popularity this year. As Bridget explains, each horse-girl is demarcated by accessories that tie into their real-life inspirations. For example, Gold Ship, the racehorse, wore a black mask with gold lettering on it, so his horse-girl counterpart wears a little black and gold cap. Her hair is pearly because the horse is grey. His jockey wore red and white, so anime Gold Ship wears a red dress. The parallels extend to their character quirks, too. “So, for example, the real horse Gold Ship was known for kicking—so in the game, when she wins, she dropkicks you and waves.” In the game, players take on the role of horse-girl manager, coaching them to win their races.
If all of this seems bizarre and a little incomprehensible to you, fear not. The rabid, inexplicable fandom the franchise has inspired is very much a zeitgeist phenomenon; you’re either fully invested in retired Japanese horses and their kawaii avatars, or you’re not.
D: Wait, this season aired in 2018? Why is it blowing up right now?
B: Because for the first time this year, the phone game got an official English release. It’s been incredibly popular in Japan for a while.
L: Can confirm that I see racehorse plushies at Village Vanguard all the time.
D: Notice how this anime came out two years before Tamayomi and looks infinitely better.
Our heroine is Special Week, a young hopeful from Hokkaido who’s headed to the big city to attend Tracen Academy, the racehorse-girl school. Curiously, real people and horse-girls coexist in this world, but we see no horse-boys.
D: Can horse-girls be with humans?
B: I don’t think so.
L: Well, if there are no horse-boys, where else would they come from, Bridget?
B: No, there are boy horses, but just not here.
D: Is that better or worse? What?
B: It’s a girls’ school.
D: The world is a girls’ school?
Credit: P.A. Works
When Special Week arrives at the track to watch a race, a weird man gropes her thighs, and she shrieks, and it’s not at all funny, and Bridget claims the game is not ecchi, so let’s hope the anime gives up on shitty jokes about squeezing girls sooner rather than later. She kicks him in the face, like a horse might.
B: Is this supposed to be the player character? I don’t like that. I don’t claim this man; he’s not me.
I learn a lot about horse-girls, not from the show but through Bridget’s commentary. Apparently, one horse-girl character is yandere because the real-life horse was violent because it was inbred? So does that mean we have an inbred horse-girl? It’s confusing, and it shouldn’t matter, but if you, like me, are the type to get caught up in worldbuilding, Umamusume may not be your favorite.
Anyhow, Special Week enjoys watching the race, and it is admittedly fun to watch the anime girls spring like mad at about 85mph. As in the game, the effect is silly and oddly charming.
And then, once again, the coach guy gropes our heroine and it’s not funny, and then the horse-girl winners perform in an idol concert to celebrate their victory.
“All of the songs are horse-themed,” Bridet tells us, whatever that means. She does not explain further. The nebulous realm of Umamusume is starting to overwhelm me, though Bridget is happy, and Daniel seems willing to embrace it.
Our girl begins attending Tracen Academy, and we’re treated to a view of a classroom full of girls with ears and tails and special identifying accessories that hint at some long backstory about a horse I know nothing about, but I am sure there are tons of amazing fandom stories about different times each girl’s corresponding horse bit someone or licked a fence or pooped on the course and fans like Bridget see it so clearly and smile and—
A void is opening beneath me.
I am always glad when people get immersed in harmless, geeky things. I am! But sometimes it is so strange, from the outside, to watch a fandom swallow people you love. I have seen friends fall to K-pop or, in the Dark Ages, to Homestuck or Hetalia, and I know they have seen me fall into my own weird pits of fixation, too. Even so, is there a word for that—for the uniquely unsettling experience of feeling torn between being happy that your friend has found something to devote themself to, and being entirely nonplussed by the nature of the something that has absorbed them?
Because that’s me during Umamusume.
I am helpless, caught adrift as the episode continues and Bridget rattles off horse facts like, “By the way, Haru Urara never won a race in her whole career, except after she retired she won a practice match!” and “Yes, these are my three favorite idiots!” and “No, Symboli Rudolf is a different horse,” and “Mejiro McQueen, she drinks a little teacup and then goes super fast! and “I love Vodka so much!” because there is a horse named Vodka. I try, from time to time, to latch onto the edges of her mad caravan, googling an occasional horse and its anime counterpart and comparing their starkly different faces, but I’m clinging on with buttery fingers.
Bridget sings along with the closing song. Her eyes sparkle.
Credit: P.A. Works
Conclusion
B: So… what did you think?
D: I think that’s the best thing we watched today.
L: …I disagree with that. Sorry, guys. I am not interested, and that’s okay. I’ve never been into horses, and maybe that’s part of it.
B: I was never a horse-girl either. I was a panda girl. You were always a big cats girl, right?
L: I love animals and yes, cats the most. But honestly? I don’t like anthropomorphized characters in general. I don’t like anything where the animal is being fetishized, and any time in anime that you give schoolgirls animal features, I am sort of put off by the reality that someone somewhere is getting off on that, and it’s just… Like, I only like anthropomorphized characters when it is done to be surreal or comedic, like Odd Taxi or Aggretsuko. Maybe it’s my own issue, or an ace thing, but it does bug me. Transformation stories are fine by me—I love something like, say, Fruits Basket or The Eccentric Family, because those are about the duality of people and internal conflict and allegory.
B: I get that. And also, I’m the biggest idol fan of our little group here, and this is very much a weird idol anime, and it differentiates itself from others with this unique take on a universe. You end up with weird stuff, and as an idol fan, that’s cool, and the concept is funny to me.
L: To me, it wasn’t funny enough. Because when people like you describe Umamusumue to me, it sounds so fun and charming, but watching it was pretty underwhelming. I think the charm must be getting into the facts and trivia.
B: I think a lot of idol anime struggle with pilots because they’re bound to establishing characters, and they all start in a similar place. “I’ve got a dream, and then all the pieces are in place, and let’s meet all the characters, and then let’s get into the actual show after five episodes.” The reason Love Live! has lasted so long is that it has such a great pilot.
L: And the reason I enjoyed Zombieland Saga is that it was different enough to make the genre feel fresh. I am not hugely into zombies or idols, but those elements together, placed in the setting of an undersung little rural prefecture, made it odd enough to feel different. Like, every genre has its tropes, sports anime too. But how do you spin them?
B: Shonen falls into that hole, too.
L: That’s why every season for every decent shonen, you get about ten more that aren’t worth remembering.
B: I think this one is more special when you play the game. Daniel, thoughts?
D: I think the animation carried it a lot for me, and I like the character designs, and I think watching human beings run around like horses remains really funny to me.
L: True enough. And P.A. Works is a good animation studio.
B: They are. We love them. They always come up during Grab Bag.
L: And I have always loved it when people get deeply passionate about things, so long as those things are not toxic. I mean, that’s what life’s about! Recently, my sister has fallen in love with a TV show for the first time in years, and I am so oddly happy for her. (She’s obsessed with the new Interview with the Vampire adaptation.) So I don’t wanna deny anyone their horse-girls, so long as they aren’t fetishizing children. And hey, that goes for all you anime creators out there!
D: Yeah, put ’em on notice.
B: Yuck the yum when the yum is illegal!
Would we watch more?
D: Probably, yeah.
B: I am going to watch more because I already love the game.
L: No, but maybe I’ll try the phone game. All of the most interesting things about this were things you told me, not things I saw in the episode.
L: So, we got lesbian baseball—
D: And then we had a much-needed palate cleanser.
L: Horse-girl racing, and salaryman badminton. I think every major sport was represented.
B: How do you feel about the wheel, Daniel?
D: Wait, is there like a “Kill Daniel” written somewhere on here that I haven’t noticed, or…?
L: Look at the title! The title!
D: …“Niche Sports Anime.” Yeah, that’s about right. This is a busted-ass wheel. I don’t see Hajime no Ippo on there.
B: There are way too many boxing anime out there, okay?
D: Is that… is that a ballroom dancing anime?
L: Yes, and it was popular, but people preferred the manga.
We had fun with our niche sports wheel, and there were some nuggets of wisdom to mine from these shows. Because yes, salarymen, while not necessarily endowed with the gift of foresight, can have good instincts. And girls can and do play baseball. The spirits of horses may not actually be transmigrated across dimensions to fill the bodies of cute girls with ears and tails in another world, but I can understand why someone might invest in that reality rather than our own. And whether or not you’re an athlete, we can respect characters—and people—who give their all to something they love doing, and being a part of.
Next time, we’ll be getting appropriately spooky with a horror anime wheel in time for Halloween. Until then, keep, um, running like a horse-girl?[end-mark]
In This Article:
Salaryman’s Club (Liden Films) Available on Crunchyroll.
Tamayomi (Studio A-Cat)Available on Amazon Prime.
Umamusume: Pretty Derby (P.A. Works)Available on Crunchyroll.
There are a fair few famous war movies that I perhaps shouldn’t admit to never having seen. It’s not that I’m avoiding critically-acclaimed films like Schindler’s List (1993) and Das Boot (1981)—I’ve just not gotten around to them yet. But if a war story has sci-fi or fantasy elements included, there’s a far higher chance of me getting around to it sooner rather than later.
Depictions of war tend to be brutal, messy, and terrifying as a rule, but the five WWII-set movies and TV episodes on this list make things even more chaotic by adding monsters, aliens, and time travel into the mix…
The lengthy D-Day landings section of Saving Private Ryan (1998) is lauded by both critics and historians for its brutally realistic depiction of the horrors of war, and I think that the paratrooper jump scene in Julius Avery’s Overlord is similarly effective in capturing a sense of fear, dread, and frenzied violence.
The film starts with an American paratrooper unit flying over France in 1944, tasked with destroying a German-controlled radio tower. The nervous energy in the plane is palpable and it soon turns to outright fear when enemy fire starts tearing apart the fuselage. The camera follows Edward Boyce (Jovan Adepo) as he scrambles to survive amidst the fiery and bloody mayhem. The sequence is viscerally terrifying—with the visuals being enhanced by excellent sound design—but it’s just the start of Boyce’s waking nightmare.
Once on the ground, Boyce and a few other survivors find each other and set out to complete their mission. But after discovering that the Nazis are conducting bizarre experiments in a secret underground lab, the film morphs from a serious war story into a fun action-horror thriller. While this genre switch might not work for everyone, I had a great time when the gruesome-yet-goofy gorefest really got going.
I’m going to be upfront with this one: Shadow in the Cloud doesn’t have the best reviews. Anyone expecting a realistic war film will definitely be disappointed. But for those who are in the mood for a pulpy B-movie that doesn’t take itself too seriously, Shadow in the Cloud absolutely delivers. Many silly, ridiculous, and unbelievable things happen over the course of the runtime—but to me that’s what makes it so much fun.
Directed by Roseanne Liang, the film is set in 1943 and starts with Maude Garrett (Chloë Grace Moretz) boarding a B-17 bomber called The Fool’s Errand in New Zealand. The otherwise all-male crew aren’t too happy with her being there (despite her papers proving that she’s assigned to the flight) and force her into the ball turret at the bottom of the plane. Once in the air, they have to contend not only with Japanese fighter planes, but also with a bizarre creature that’s clinging to the outside of the bomber. All of the silly chaos that ensues is set to a fantastic synth-heavy score, composed by Mahuia Bridgman-Cooper.
Dan Trachtenberg’s Predator: Killer of Killers is split into four parts that follow various Predators hunting for prey in different time periods and places. The third section of the animated film—titled “The Bullet”—is set in 1942 and follows John J. Torres (Rick Gonzalez), a Wildcat fighter pilot with the U.S. Navy who is stationed in the North Atlantic Ocean. When a mysterious and unseen aircraft begins attacking both sides indiscriminately, Torres puts his life on the line in an effort to save his fellow soldiers from the alien threat.
Although “The Bullet” only totals around 20 minutes, a lot of action is packed in, with the animated medium being used to its maximum potential (which is true of the entire film!). We get to see Torres take on the Predator in an aerial dogfight and while the high-flying action alone is exhilarating, extra oomph is added thanks to his quick and creative thinking each time an extraterrestrial curveball is thrown his way.
It wasn’t all that long ago that I expressed my love for this season 6 episode of The X-Files on a list of fantastic long takes, but I couldn’t pass up including it here too. The episode starts with FBI agent Fox Mulder (David Duchovny) boarding the SS Queen Anne, a luxury passenger liner that inexplicably disappeared in 1939. Once aboard, he tries to explain to everyone he meets that they’ve time-traveled to 1998, but then it dawns on him that he’s the one who’s out of time.
With Mulder now stuck in the past on a Nazi-infested ship at the outbreak of WWII, he does everything he can to throw a wrench into their plans. Multiple long shots are used throughout the episode, tracking not just Mulder through the ship, but also Dana Scully (Gillian Anderson) through the FBI office as she attempts to rescue her foolhardy and troublemaking partner.
The long takes aren’t just a gimmick—they add a particularly propulsive drive to the fun and tense story. Oh and Mulder punches multiple Nazis, so what more could you really want?
“How Zeke Got Religion” — Love, Death + Robots (2025)
This season 4 episode of animated anthology Love, Death + Robots may only be 15 minutes long, but it’s a wild thrill ride from start to finish. Directed by Diego Porral and based on John McNichol’s short story “How Zeke Got Religion at 20,000 Feet” (which you can read in SNAFU Resurrection), the titular Zeke (Keston John) is a solider aboard The Liberty Belle—a B-17 tasked with bombing a Nazi-occupied church in France.
The crew don’t know what’s going on inside the church, but we see that mere seconds before the bombs drop the Nazis successfully complete a ritual sacrifice that unleashes a fallen angel. This episode manages to be simultaneously horrifying and beautiful. The unholy creature, of course, is the source of the horror—not only does it create a wealth of gore, but its design is inventively scary. The beauty comes from the style of animation itself, with the bold use of color being a particular highlight.
The most obvious oversight on this list is likely Captain America: The First Avenger (2011)—a film that I absolutely adore (Cap is my favorite superhero) but that doesn’t really need additional recommendations from me, given how popular it already is. If there are any others shows or movies that belong on this list—be they obvious or obscure—please leave them in the comments below![end-mark]
[Error: Irreparable invalid markup ('<a [...] h-[15px]">') in entry. Owner must fix manually. Raw contents below.]
<p class="syndicationauthor">Posted by Christina Orlando</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/">https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824069">https://reactormag.com/?p=824069</a></p><post-hero class="wp-block-post-hero js-post-hero post-hero post-hero-vertical">
<div class="container container-desktop">
<div class="flex flex-col mx-auto post-hero-container">
<div class="post-hero-content">
<div class="post-hero-tags font-aktiv text-xs tracking-[0.5px] font-medium uppercase">
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/articles/books/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag Books 0">
Books
</a>
</span>
<span class="mr-3">
<i class="inline-block w-2 h-2 rounded-full mr-[5px] bg-blue"></i>
<a href="https://reactormag.com/tag/book-reviews/" class="inline-block link-no-animation" aria-label="Link to term or tag book reviews 1">
book reviews
</a>
</span>
</div>
<h2 class="post-hero-title text-h1"><i>The Library at Hellebore</i> by Cassandra Khaw Is a Vicious Dark Academia</h2>
<div class="prose post-hero-description prose--post-hero">One of Cassandra Khaw’s most fascinating, horrifying worlds to date—and a great place for new readers to meet their brilliant mind.</div>
<div class="post-hero-wrapper">
<div class="post-hero-inner">
<p class="post-hero-author text-xs font-aktiv uppercase font-medium [&_a]:link-hover">By <a href="https://reactormag.com/author/martin-cahill/" title="Posts by Martin Cahill" class="author url fn" rel="author">Martin Cahill</a></p>
<span class="post-hero-symbol relative top-[-2px] hidden tablet:block">|</span>
<p class="text-xs uppercase post-hero-publish font-aktiv">
Published on September 17, 2025
</p>
</div>
</div>
<div class="quick-access post-hero-quick-access mt-[17px] tablet:hidden">
<div class="flex gap-[30px] tablet:gap-6">
<a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/#comments" class="flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase translate-x-[1px] translate-y-[1px]">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 18 18" aria-label="comment" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-comment-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-comment-quick-access-">Comment</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<path fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" d="M6.3 18a.9.9 0 0 1-.9-.9v-2.7H1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 0 12.6V1.8A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 1.8 0h14.4A1.8 1.8 0 0 1 18 1.8v10.8a1.8 1.8 0 0 1-1.8 1.8h-5.49l-3.33 3.339a.917.917 0 0 1-.63.261H6.3Z" />
<path stroke="#000" d="M5.9 14.4v-.5H1.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3-1.3V1.8A1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.8.5h14.4a1.3 1.3 0 0 1 1.3 1.3v10.8a1.3 1.3 0 0 1-1.3 1.3h-5.698l-.146.147-3.324 3.333a.417.417 0 0 1-.282.12H6.3a.4.4 0 0 1-.4-.4v-2.7Z" />
</g>
</svg>
0
</a>
<details class="relative quick-access-details">
<summary class="quick-access-share flex items-center text-sm font-aktiv tracking-[0.6px] font-semibold uppercase">
<svg class="w-[22px] h-[22px] mr-[7px] icon-hover" viewbox="0 0 22 22" aria-label="share" role="img" aria-hidden="true" aria-labelledby="icon-share-new-quick-access-">
<title id="icon-share-new-quick-access-">Share New</title>
<g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="11" fill="#FFF" fill-rule="nonzero" />
<circle cx="11" cy="11" r="10.5" stroke="#000" />
<path fill="#FFF" d="M5.993 13.464c.675 0 1.323-.266 1.806-.743l4.11 2.396a2.639 2.639 0 0 0 .368 2.451 2.583 2.583 0 0 0 2.227 1.043 2.59 2.59 0 0 0 2.09-1.3 2.64 2.64 0 0 0 .08-2.477 2.58 2.58 0 0 0-4.292-.54L8.344 11.94c.28-.616.31-1.319.086-1.958l3.952-2.303a2.564 2.564 0 0 0 4.263-.537 2.623 2.623 0 0 0-.078-2.46 2.573 2.573 0 0 0-2.075-1.293 2.566 2.566 0 0 0-2.213 1.033 2.622 2.622 0 0 0-.37 2.433L7.96 9.158a2.573 2.573 0 0 0-4.316.603 2.632 2.632 0 0 0 .172 2.501 2.58 2.58 0 0 0 2.178 1.202Z" />
<path fill="#000" d="M6.936 9.577c.322 0 .631.137.859.383.228.245.355.577.355.924 0 .347-.127.68-.355.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.859.383c-.322 0-.63-.138-.858-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.356-.925c0-.347.129-.679.356-.924.228-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm6.17-3.837c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.924 0 .347-.128.68-.356.925a1.172 1.172 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.924.227-.245.536-.383.858-.383Zm0 7.883c.323 0 .631.138.86.383.227.245.355.578.355.925 0 .346-.128.679-.356.924a1.171 1.171 0 0 1-.858.383c-.322 0-.631-.138-.859-.383a1.36 1.36 0 0 1-.355-.925c0-.346.128-.678.356-.923.227-.245.536-.383.858-.384Zm-6.17-.681c.499 0 .978-.21 1.334-.586l3.036 1.888a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .272 1.93c.385.555 1.003.863 1.645.822.641-.04 1.221-.425 1.544-1.024a2.203 2.203 0 0 0 .059-1.952c-.286-.62-.841-1.044-1.48-1.13-.637-.085-1.272.18-1.69.705l-2.984-1.854c.207-.486.23-1.04.064-1.543l2.92-1.815c.415.522 1.046.784 1.68.7.633-.086 1.184-.507 1.468-1.123a2.188 2.188 0 0 0-.058-1.938c-.32-.595-.895-.977-1.532-1.018-.638-.041-1.251.264-1.635.813a2.179 2.179 0 0 0-.273 1.917L8.389 9.55c-.423-.534-1.07-.798-1.715-.702-.645.096-1.2.54-1.472 1.177a2.194 2.194 0 0 0 .126 1.97c.352.59.958.948 1.61.947Z" />
</g>
</svg>
Share
</summary>
<div class="quick-access-bubble">
<ul class="flex gap-6 text-black list-none">
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=<i>The Library at Hellebore</i> by Cassandra Khaw Is a Vicious Dark Academia&url=https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/” target=”_blank” title=”Twitter”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[15px]"="h-[15px]"" width="18" height="15" viewbox="0 0 18 15" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="twitter" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M17.7143 2.56767C17.2122 3.28347 16.6053 3.89336 15.8934 4.39734C15.9009 4.4996 15.9046 4.65298 15.9046 4.8575C15.9046 5.80703 15.7623 6.75472 15.4775 7.7006C15.1928 8.64649 14.76 9.55401 14.1793 10.4232C13.5986 11.2924 12.9073 12.0611 12.1055 12.7295C11.3037 13.3978 10.3371 13.931 9.20558 14.329C8.07408 14.7271 6.86392 14.9262 5.57505 14.9262C3.54435 14.9262 1.68601 14.3966 0 13.3375C0.262269 13.3667 0.554506 13.3813 0.876722 13.3813C2.56274 13.3813 4.06514 12.8774 5.38397 11.8694C4.59717 11.8548 3.8928 11.6192 3.27085 11.1627C2.6489 10.7062 2.22178 10.1237 1.98949 9.41523C2.23677 9.45175 2.46531 9.47001 2.67513 9.47001C2.99734 9.47001 3.31581 9.42984 3.63053 9.3495C2.79127 9.1815 2.09627 8.77431 1.5455 8.12789C0.99474 7.48148 0.719362 6.73099 0.719362 5.87641V5.83259C1.22891 6.11015 1.77592 6.25988 2.36041 6.28179C1.86584 5.96041 1.47245 5.54043 1.1802 5.02184C0.887961 4.50325 0.741842 3.94084 0.741842 3.3346C0.741842 2.69184 0.906694 2.09656 1.2364 1.54875C2.1431 2.63707 3.24649 3.50807 4.54659 4.16178C5.84669 4.8155 7.23857 5.17887 8.72226 5.25192C8.66232 4.97436 8.63234 4.70411 8.63234 4.44116C8.63234 3.46241 8.9864 2.62793 9.69452 1.9377C10.4027 1.24746 11.2588 0.902344 12.2629 0.902344C13.3119 0.902344 14.1962 1.27485 14.9155 2.01987C15.7323 1.86648 16.5004 1.58162 17.2197 1.16529C16.9425 2.00526 16.4104 2.65532 15.6236 3.11548C16.3205 3.04244 17.0174 2.85984 17.7143 2.56767Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/" target="_blank" title="Facebook">
<svg class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" fill="currentColor" viewbox="0 0 12 22" width="100%" height="100%" display="block" transitionduration="normal" transitionproperty="none" transitiontimingfunction="ease-out" class="w-[9px] h-[18px]" aria-label="facebook" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M11.558.004L8.677 0C5.44 0 3.349 2.125 3.349 5.416v2.496H.452A.45.45 0 000 8.36v3.618a.45.45 0 00.452.447h2.897v9.127A.45.45 0 003.8 22h3.778c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.448v-9.127h3.387c.25 0 .451-.2.451-.447l.003-3.618a.452.452 0 00-.456-.448h-3.39V5.795c0-1.017.245-1.534 1.582-1.534h1.941c.25 0 .452-.2.452-.447V.457a.45.45 0 00-.452-.448l.01-.005z" fill-rule="nonzero">
</path>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/&media=&description=<i>The Library at Hellebore</i> by Cassandra Khaw Is a Vicious Dark Academia” target=”_blank” title=”Pinterest”>
<svg class=" w-[18px]="w-[18px]" h-[18px]"="h-[18px]"" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="pinterest" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M16.4962 4.49458C17.2844 5.84153 17.6786 7.31473 17.6786 8.91423C17.6786 10.5137 17.2844 11.9888 16.4962 13.3396C15.7079 14.6904 14.6384 15.7599 13.2876 16.5482C11.9368 17.3364 10.4617 17.7306 8.86223 17.7306C8.01273 17.7306 7.17856 17.6081 6.35967 17.3632C6.81121 16.6515 7.10967 16.0239 7.25508 15.4806C7.32396 15.2203 7.53059 14.413 7.87498 13.0584C8.02804 13.3568 8.30738 13.6151 8.71299 13.8332C9.1186 14.0513 9.55483 14.1604 10.0217 14.1604C10.9477 14.1604 11.7742 13.8983 12.5013 13.374C13.2283 12.8498 13.7908 12.1285 14.1888 11.2101C14.5867 10.2918 14.7857 9.25862 14.7857 8.11066C14.7857 7.2382 14.558 6.41933 14.1027 5.65402C13.6473 4.88871 12.9872 4.26499 12.1224 3.78285C11.2576 3.3007 10.2819 3.05964 9.19513 3.05964C8.39156 3.05964 7.64157 3.1706 6.94513 3.39254C6.2487 3.61448 5.65751 3.90912 5.17154 4.27647C4.68556 4.64382 4.26848 5.06665 3.92026 5.54497C3.57205 6.02329 3.31567 6.51882 3.15113 7.03157C2.98659 7.54433 2.90432 8.05708 2.90432 8.56984C2.90432 9.36576 3.05738 10.066 3.3635 10.6706C3.66962 11.2752 4.11732 11.6999 4.70661 11.9448C4.93621 12.0367 5.08161 11.9601 5.14284 11.7152C5.15814 11.6617 5.18876 11.5431 5.23467 11.3594C5.28059 11.1757 5.3112 11.0609 5.32651 11.015C5.37243 10.839 5.33034 10.6744 5.20024 10.5214C4.80993 10.0545 4.61478 9.47673 4.61478 8.78795C4.61478 7.63233 5.01464 6.63936 5.81439 5.809C6.61414 4.97864 7.66069 4.56346 8.95406 4.56346C10.1097 4.56346 11.0108 4.87723 11.6575 5.50479C12.3042 6.13234 12.6275 6.94739 12.6275 7.94994C12.6275 9.25097 12.3654 10.3568 11.8412 11.2675C11.3169 12.1783 10.6454 12.6336 9.82651 12.6336C9.35967 12.6336 8.98468 12.4672 8.70151 12.1343C8.41835 11.8013 8.33034 11.4015 8.43748 10.9346C8.49871 10.6668 8.60011 10.309 8.74169 9.86129C8.88327 9.41359 8.99807 9.01946 9.08608 8.67889C9.17409 8.33833 9.21809 8.04943 9.21809 7.81219C9.21809 7.42953 9.11478 7.11193 8.90814 6.85938C8.70151 6.60683 8.40687 6.48055 8.02422 6.48055C7.54972 6.48055 7.14794 6.69866 6.81886 7.13489C6.48977 7.57112 6.32524 8.11448 6.32524 8.76499C6.32524 9.32367 6.4209 9.7905 6.61223 10.1655L5.47575 14.964C5.34564 15.4997 5.2959 16.177 5.32651 16.9959C3.74997 16.2994 2.47575 15.2242 1.50381 13.7701C0.531863 12.316 0.0458984 10.6974 0.0458984 8.91423C0.0458984 7.31473 0.440027 5.83962 1.2283 4.48884C2.01657 3.13807 3.08607 2.06857 4.43684 1.2803C5.78761 0.492029 7.26273 0.0979004 8.86223 0.0979004C10.4617 0.0979004 11.9368 0.492029 13.2876 1.2803C14.6384 2.06857 15.7079 3.13999 16.4962 4.49458Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</svg>
</a>
</li>
<li class="flex">
<a class="flex items-center hover:text-red" href="https://reactormag.com/feed/" target="_blank" title="RSS Feed">
<svg class="w-[17px] h-[17px]" width="18" height="18" viewbox="0 0 18 18" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="rss feed" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<g clip-path="url(#clip0_1051_121783)">
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" />
<path d="M2.67871 17.4143C2.12871 17.4143 1.65771 17.2183 1.26571 16.8263C0.873713 16.4343 0.678046 15.9636 0.678713 15.4143C0.678713 14.8643 0.874713 14.3933 1.26671 14.0013C1.65871 13.6093 2.12938 13.4136 2.67871 13.4143C3.22871 13.4143 3.69971 13.6103 4.09171 14.0023C4.48371 14.3943 4.67938 14.865 4.67871 15.4143C4.67871 15.9643 4.48271 16.4353 4.09071 16.8273C3.69871 17.2193 3.22805 17.415 2.67871 17.4143ZM14.6787 17.4143C14.6787 15.481 14.312 13.6683 13.5787 11.9763C12.8454 10.2843 11.841 8.80097 10.5657 7.52631C9.29171 6.25164 7.80871 5.24764 6.11671 4.51431C4.42471 3.78097 2.61205 3.41431 0.678713 3.41431V0.414307C3.02871 0.414307 5.23705 0.860306 7.30371 1.75231C9.37038 2.64431 11.1704 3.85664 12.7037 5.38931C14.237 6.92264 15.4497 8.72264 16.3417 10.7893C17.2337 12.856 17.6794 15.0643 17.6787 17.4143H14.6787ZM8.67871 17.4143C8.67871 15.1976 7.89971 13.31 6.34171 11.7513C4.78371 10.1926 2.89605 9.41364 0.678713 9.41431V6.41431C2.21205 6.41431 3.64538 6.70197 4.97871 7.27731C6.31205 7.85264 7.47471 8.63597 8.46671 9.62731C9.45805 10.6186 10.2414 11.781 10.8167 13.1143C11.392 14.4476 11.6794 15.881 11.6787 17.4143H8.67871Z" fill="currentColor" fill-opacity="0.2" />
</g>
<defs>
<clippath id="clip0_1051_121783">
<rect width="17" height="17" fill="white" transform="translate(0.678711 0.414307)" />
</clippath>
</defs>
</svg>
</a>
</li>
</ul>
</div>
</details>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="post-hero-media ">
<figure class="w-full h-auto post-hero-image">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="740" height="407" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-The-Library-at-Hellebore-740x407.png" class="w-full object-cover" alt="Cover of The Library at Hellebore by Cassandra Khaw." srcset="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-The-Library-at-Hellebore-740x407.png 740w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-The-Library-at-Hellebore-1100x605.png 1100w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-The-Library-at-Hellebore-768x422.png 768w, https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/review-The-Library-at-Hellebore.png 1400w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 740px) 100vw, 740px" /> </figure>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</post-hero>
<div class="wp-block-more-from-category">
<div>
</div>
</div>
<p>Alessa Li has a problem. Well, several problems. She has been forcibly relocated to Hellebore Technical Institute for the Gifted, which wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world if it wasn’t literally one of the worst places in the world—an academy for the dangerously powerful, those for whom ruin runs in their veins, many of them one bad day away from unleashing apocalypse. She’s been paired with a roommate who she cannot stand and whom she may have quite possibly murdered (we’ll come back to that); she has a magic within her, and it is hungry, maybe just as hungry as Alessa is for escape; and to top it all off, she’s currently trapped in the library at Hellebore with a handful of students who survived the school-wide massacre, as the staff has suddenly moved to literally devour every student present. </p>
<p>Hey, Dark Academia genre? Cassandra Khaw just said, “Bet?” and pushed all their chips into the middle of the table.</p>
<p>If you’ve read Khaw’s work before, then you know what you’re in for: compulsive, complicated, contradictory characters each trying to navigate the otherworldly circumstances of their lives. Prose that sizzles and spats. Worldbuilding that is sublime, imagery that will make your jaw tense with the beautiful grotesquerie described, and a story that will make you pissed for these characters, and mourn their losses. And let me tell you, there are losses. Lots of ‘em. But that’s also what makes this book so special, and what elevates this beyond a gory pick-em-off story is the tenacity of hope, the value of trying to survive even when the odds are against you, and making peace with the inevitable. </p>
<p>It’s no secret that Khaw fulfills the promise of the premise, that while these students are trapped in the Library, with a hungry faculty salivating outside, well… not everyone gets out alive. Forced together to survive in terrible circumstances, this group of students do their best to do right by each other, (most of them, anyway). Among the remaining students are an illegitimate son of Lucifer, a chosen voice for an eldritch force, a hive mind drone losing herself to the creature within, an augur who reads his own entrails, and of course, our Alessa, whose dangerous power lives in her body, and is of bodies, specifically, manipulation of yours, hers, and anyone within reach, down to the cellular level. But for all that the Faculty are waiting for these students to sell each other out, manipulate, maim, and sacrifice the others to save their own skin, the majority of them really try not to. </p>
<section class="wp-block-shop-the-book shop-the-book">
<h2 class="shop-the-book-headline">Buy the Book</h2>
<div class="shop-the-book-content">
<figure class="shop-the-book-image-desktop image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/The-Library-at-Hellebore.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="The Library at Hellebore" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<div class="flex items-center">
<figure class="shop-the-book-image-mobile image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/The-Library-at-Hellebore.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="The Library at Hellebore" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<h3 class="shop-the-book-title text-h3">The Library at Hellebore</h3>
<p class="shop-the-book-author">Cassandra Khaw</p>
</div>
</div>
<button type="button" class="inline-block px-8 py-4 text-center btn tablet:py-3 text-h6 bg-red text-white shop-the-book-button" id="buy_book" data-trigger="modal" data-target="#modal-1758298882" aria-open="false" aria-label="Buy Book">
<span class="inline-flex items-center button-label btn-label">
Buy Book
</span>
</button>
</div>
</div>
<div id="modal-1758298882" class="shop-the-book-modal test">
<div class="shop-the-book-modal-inner">
<button class="js-modal-close absolute top-5 right-5 z-10 test" type="button" aria-label="icon-close">
<svg class="w-[19px] h-[19px]" width="18" height="19" viewbox="0 0 18 19" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-label="close" role="img" aria-hidden="true">
<path d="M1 17L17 1" stroke="black" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
<path d="M1 17L17 1" stroke="black" stroke-opacity="0.2" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
<path d="M17 17.0809L1 1.08093" stroke="black" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
<path d="M17 17.0809L1 1.08093" stroke="black" stroke-opacity="0.2" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" />
</svg>
</button>
<div class="shop-the-book-modal-content">
<figure class="shop-the-book-modal-image-desktop image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/The-Library-at-Hellebore.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="The Library at Hellebore" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<div class="flex items-center">
<figure class="shop-the-book-modal-image-mobile image-cover">
<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="300" height="450" src="https://reactormag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/The-Library-at-Hellebore.jpg" class="attachment-full size-full" alt="The Library at Hellebore" /> </figure>
<div class="grow shrink basis-0">
<h3 class="shop-the-book-modal-title">The Library at Hellebore</h3>
<p class="shop-the-book-modal-author">Cassandra Khaw</p>
</div>
</div>
<p class="shop-the-book-modal-label">Buy this book from:</p>
<ul class="not-prose ebook-links ebook-links-shortcode"><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0DDJB5V76?tag=tordotcomgeneral-20" data-book-title="The Library at Hellebore" data-book-store="Amazon"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">Amazon</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="https://www.anrdoezrs.net/links/7992675/type/dlg/sid/tordotcomgeneral/https://www.barnesandnoble.com/s/9781250877819" data-book-title="The Library at Hellebore" data-book-store="Barnes and Noble"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">Barnes and Noble</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="http://itunes.apple.com/us/book/isbn9781250877826" data-book-title="The Library at Hellebore" data-book-store="iBooks"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">iBooks</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="https://www.indiebound.org/book/9781250877819" data-book-title="The Library at Hellebore" data-book-store="IndieBound"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">IndieBound</span></a></li><li><a class="btn" target="_blank" href="https://www.target.com/s?searchTerm=9781250877819" data-book-title="The Library at Hellebore" data-book-store="Target"><span class="inline-flex items-center button-label text-h6 text-white font-aktiv">Target</span></a></li></ul>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</section>
<p>Khaw has crafted an engaging, bittersweet collection of outsiders, whose otherness is literalized by their enrollment in Hellebore. While there are some that fit the bill of Darwinian fuck-you survivalists, Alessa and those she spends the most time with understand that they’re in community with each other— that here, at the very least, they can all recognize in each other some spark of humanity, even as their humanity might very well be fading as they face gods, monsters, and magic. And Alessa, bless her, may be a prickly, irritable, bit of an asshole, but even she sees the moment for what it is: If they’re going to die, they’re not going to do it to each other. And if they’re going to go out, they’re going to go out swinging. Khaw provides texture to this thesis in many ways; some students are little beacons of hope, while others are slick opportunists, with many in between these poles. But, they all want to live. And Alessa, despite not wanting to be, becomes the glue keeping them together and united as long as possible; for someone who has been through the wringer and seen the worst, Khaw paints Alessa kindly; it may be because of that horror that she can see the value in working together as long as possible, to say fuck the monsters, we’re not throwing each other to the wolves. In a book with this much blood and guts, the most heart we see is in the actions of Alessa and her comrades as they work to make it through the worst of situations as best as possible. It’s like what if Star Trek’s Kobayashi Maru was a writhing, conglomeration of souls intent on devouring you. </p>
<p>One of my favorite aspects of the novel is the timeline maneuvering that Khaw deftly engages in; we meet Alessa at, technically, the scene of a crime where she supposedly murdered her roommate. Then we find ourselves in the Library, suddenly trapped. And then we’re back at the very beginning, when she first arrives at Hellebore where all of this story starts. The time-hopping took me a few chapters to get used to, but once you see the pattern, it becomes an irresistible device with which Khaw paints a bittersweet picture of Alessa’s reluctant friendships, her frustrating attempts to escape, the growing dread of the Faculty as their hunger becomes less and less hidden, and how the past influences the present dire situation. It’s really brilliantly done, and scene after scene, this story shines like blacklight in a blood-spattered parlor. </p>
<p><em>The Library at Hellebore</em> is a fantastic place for new readers of Khaw to meet their brilliant mind, which worked like hell to give us one of the most fascinating, horrifying worlds of theirs to date. (I haven’t even mentioned The Librarian yet; let’s just say you don’t want to owe a late fee to this being.) Through Alessa’s sharp, incisive point of view, the world of Hellebore is brought to life—her dry and wry observations, her tactical and dextrous perspective when her back is against the wall. Alessa’s voice is that of a predator who knows larger, hungrier beasts lurk nearby. And through her sharp-as-nails spirit and her tenacious heart, we see that when you’ve been on the outside your whole life, when the world wants to eat you, it’s always worth standing up and trying to survive. And <em>The Library At Hellebore</em> and Cassandra Khaw ultimately teach us this: Even if you get eaten, that doesn’t mean you have to let yourself be swallowed. At least, not without a fight. [end-mark]</p>
<div style="height:5px" aria-hidden="true" class="wp-block-spacer"></div>
<p class="has-sm-font-size"><em><a href="https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250877826/thelibraryathellebore/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">The Library at Hellebore</a></em> is published by Nightfire.</p>
<p>The post <a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/"><i>The Library at Hellebore</i> by Cassandra Khaw Is a Vicious Dark Academia</a> appeared first on <a href="https://reactormag.com">Reactor</a>.</p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/">https://reactormag.com/book-review-the-library-at-hellebore-by-cassandra-khaw/</a></p><p class="ljsyndicationlink"><a href="https://reactormag.com/?p=824069">https://reactormag.com/?p=824069</a></p>